also 1000th post belongs to me 
ami like neutrals! we need to have a serious talk about that.
on a more serious note i usually can’t truly analyze reads D1 especially except things of which people might reveal something about themselves without realizing that it does…
so instead of a reads list, you get a vibe check. its basically a reads list but it sucks.
good bois - marshal, sulit, emilia
bad bois - arete, jgoes, chloe
this is a combination of logic and just my own gut. emilia seems like strong independent thinker, sulit makes good reads, idk i just feel like this isn’t marshal scum behavior
idk i didn’t like arete’s read on amelia, seemed weird that he reads based on newbieness. consider amelia town if arete is groupscum. jgoes and chloe seem … eh … well they could be trying more instead of discrediting their ability.
also marshal and vulgard interaction was weird - i really like vulgard up until that point. his response just seem too defensive in a way where he tries to discredit marshal’s read based on him being the only person that was read.
i was gonna do a hot take with vulgard and arete having at least one scum as a d1 prediction but then vulgard claims merc. seems to make sense
vulgard claiming merc, shooting out reads, claims to read their targets as town, and then claims bleeding - not sure what to make out of this. Vulgard seems too sure on his reads on his targets just based off D1. But he’s a fucking neut, his reads are probably not genuine in the first place. should you heal them? idk im really still thinking about that.
P.S.
you shouldn’t rlly have said this tbh.
2 Likes
why are you concerned about whether i said something or not and not what i said
1 Like
That’s not necessarily what I meant. I don’t know if I agree with having jgoes as a bad boi since he hasn’t said anything readable. In my eyes he’s null. I do agree with Chloe’s placement. I also very much believe Emilia and Marshal are town, and the other options I haven’t decided.
ok one more question for you. why do you want people who haven’t spoken yet to start talking? is their insight really that important? like my insight for instance, was similar to yours
Honestly that statement about the non talkers wasn’t terribly serious. However, I WOULD like to see how someone acts simply because I don’t know that.
If you had that thought in mind, do you not get more information by not saying that? For instance, if I were EK and I saw this post, you better believe I’m going to make sure I’m saying something D1.
that wasn’t where i was getting at. allow me to rephrase, do you think Magnus’ input is important here?
Not speaking is NAI; the statement was purposely made to draw you out so I can see where your head is.
While I feel that it isn’t necessary, I want to see how he reacts to the information so I can judge his actions as best I can
I see. For future reference, I should just point out that I started talking before I actually saw that post. Ping is a powerful tool
Slanking seems to be one of the most common scum tactics employed recently and it occurs because players don’t push them. I see nothing wrong with Amelia pushing inactives to speak.