@Centuries 147?
alright, I re-read some people in my nullzone overnight to try to sort them, I went roughly least posts -> most posts to sort them so that I could do more but that did mean I didnāt get to the highposters
going to just post what I came up with and then take a look at night stuff
Appel
Summary
This one is like ā¦ my gut is telling me town but my brain is telling me scum, and Iām not sure why my gut is saying that
also she has like five posts, which makes things harder
the thing thatās pinging me about her mainly is her hedginess, like she has a lot of posts like
which are super hedgy and not really drawing any conclusions, which is also something sheās done in her scum games (e.g. SF V)
tl;dr slight scumlean but I need more than 5 posts to read her
Amelia
Summary
Literally all I have to say about this slot is āhas activity tells and isnāt being active,ā like, none of her posts are actually game-related
closest thing I found to a game-related post is this one:
which ā¦ vaguely feels like itās trying too hard to look comfortable? I guess?
honestly Iām just going to hope that someone mechresolves her ĀÆ_(ć)_/ĀÆ
Wazza
Summary
I was concerned a bit at first because posts like
felt out of place, like, why would that be the only thing you comment on
but after reading his Chloe analysis Iām a lot more comfortable with him being town
second quote goes to the Isopost, itās long so Iām not going to post the whole thing
I think Wazza having a serious push at this point is a good look for him since heās not trying to go UTR, I also like the depth of analysis in the Isopost (Wazza is capable of having real pushes as a wolf, but speaking as someone whoās been on the receiving end of those pushes he basically just picks one thing and tunneltunneltunnels rather than actually trying to analyze)
I also thought this comment in particular was a weirdly good look, like, if scum is paying any attention to the game at all they definitely caught Leafiaās super obvious Priest softs
Overall I think Wazza is probably town
Soulshade
Summary
mrrrr
I donāt like any of his posts
but I think they probably come from town?
like I donāt want to clear him off the scumclaim, in my experience scum are more likely to claim scum because wHy WoUlD sCuM cLaIm ScUm, but posts like
are combative/aggressive in ways that donāt normally come from scum
slight townlean for now
would like to see some actual takes from him
Calculus
Summary
This one is going to be short because Iām running out of time + I already commented on him a bit
a thing that I realized is that Iām pretty sure this post:
came after people had already commented on how it was kind of wolfy that he had nothing but scumreads (not positive on this and if Iām wrong that negates the read)
Iām inclined to think that scum in that situation would change what they were doing rather than continuing to have nothing but scumreads
the āfind scum donāt make townreadsā approach is fairly common among newer/less experienced players, and some sites do it a lot more, I donāt think itās intrinsically wolfy if theyāre not familiar with towncore + PoE based strategies
also the priest hardclaiming on D1 and dying N1 with no protection is certainly a thing
2 Likes
ā¦Leafia?
Iām guessing it was a protective dodge.
Also, weāre probably in a Cult game judging by KP alone.
Pretty sure most people here protect the stronger players over d1 hardclaims? I dunno.
I kinda feel like this is the type of kill an attempted dodger makes.
Didnāt re-eval kat overnight? I did and I kinda feel like they canāt be groupscum at least. They feel alone in the thread.
Neutral is not off the table.
Like
This is literally the opposite of the read you had yesterday
which was also one of the strongest reads you had
2 Likes
I re-read their posts, and while I still find the instant OMGUS super annoying, it probably doesnāt come from groupscum. Didnāt see anyone else defending kat or even trying to defend kat, which was weird, too.
I could see it from a neutral annoyed about me scumreading them, but I donāt think groupscum!kat does it in their position. I still donāt think katās a villager, but I think them being groupscum is less likely.
Here are my logs from last night - without my role/actions, and a few other things i only wanted to out if i died.
Allies w Cent: gorta feels townie / genuinely solvey, but not super present. Very similar to sfol62 tbh. Gave us a pool of people he might have SFād. Centuries didnt contribute a ton but I still V read him. Ask them for the explanations for my reads - paraphrased. And if Vul flips scum, scumbuds could be [redacted] (just removed these since Vul is still alive).
V
Cent
TBE
Leaf
PKRArete
Kat (unless scum w exactly vul, or nk. Re-read soulread says v/neut)
Gorta
Frost
AT
Wazz
PKItaly
Calc
Soul
AppelVul
Amelia
W
1 Like
I have many questions. I thought you were townreading me, why do you want to yeet me now? The way this is phrased suggests you view me as dead in the water.