Forum game: Rate the "skill" of the player above you

Off-Topic (Thronepass)
#61

His language barrier arguably is one of the factors preventing him from changing his lurker AI all-round.

I think if he tried to townlead in his next town game despite him maybe having awful grammar it could benefit his faction greatly.

Overall I find him proficient in his current AI, I would encourage him to try and vary up his playstyle so he can try new plays as scum without immediately getting FOSed, I think this would lead to more dynamic interactions and a more engaging experience overall.

1 Like
#62

marcus is consistently good as all allingments but I feel like he hasnā€™t been handed a posiiton to really show his true power yet.

(also I agree iā€™m shit at Mafia the only good town games I have are where Iā€™'m peeked or discovered town very early on)

5 Likes
#63

A pretty solid player, but I have in the past overestimated their scum play skill.

1 Like
#64

Mole is the best host ever

although I have yet to see sufficient amounts of their gameplay to properly critique their scum and town plays

5 Likes
#65

Livicus is one of the old player in the forum.

His scumread are usually good, but when he is scum :thinking:

#66

Insanity, the young little one, who tags along with us and then stays relatively quiet but is always a good guy and sheeps at the right moments

and what do you mean by ā€œoldā€

#67

Liv usually plays well as town, and is serious enough to focus on the game, yet not serious enough to go ape-shit when someone does something wrong. (And also request for GIFs. Cheater.) Itā€™s a good mix, and Iā€™ve never seen anyone pissed off at him because of it.
Iā€™ve never seen them as wolf.

1 Like
#68

mislynching you for cred in the tourney was fun :^)

i donā€™t have much to say really though

#69

Too easily found as scum, townplay is not very accurate.
You want to see Icibalus in the other team.

#70

okay iā€™m just going to stop you right there
iā€™m shit often but Iā€™m NOT actually so bad you donā€™t want me as a buddy

firstly, my wolf play is realtively strong when you actually look at the fucking results of it
secondly, if iā€™m peeked or consensus townie from early on my reads get more accurate

i know iā€™m bad but youā€™re being judgemental there

1 Like
#71

also theyā€™re alright as town, havenā€™t seen their wolf play enough to be sure. Their reads are pretty alright but they suffer from a tone that often gets them mislynched.

however their EoD play from Fates makes me think they have a ton of potential if they can get a better tone

#72

Plague/10

2 Likes
#73

Didnā€™t play with her :^)

#74

my entire fatal flaw is rushing things
itā€™s how iā€™ve carried my team to several losses, time after time

#75

I wasnā€™t in a tourney.

#76

the FoL tourney, remember?
where I was Devout King and fucked everyoneā€™s minds.

1 Like
#77

ā€¦I think I do.
Iā€™m not sure.
Was I cult that game?
Wait I remember.
Screw you.

1 Like
#78

yeee

1 Like
#79

Selfish, manipulative, piece of crap.
Will do anything to win, even sacrifice their teammates.
/s
(Actually a good player. When town.)

#80

Errr, why exactly is everyone bashing Ici? As town heā€™s fairly skilled and a better-than-average scumhunter while his gambits as scum arenā€™t bad either.

IMO, you rely too much on mechanics to deduce in general. Iā€™d focus more on trying to read players by their motivation, association, and whatnot as deduction by mechanics depends far too much on the setup to work.