Polik tried to convert like two times, then you come along - cooldown active - Orange or Methnor.
Polik tried to convert me one time, then you must be converted N2 - cooldown active - Night 4, last spike trap kicked in and cult leader died making you the next cult leader and if he tried to convert Methnor at this point - cooldown active at N5
Either way, it’s just only you and that person.