FW1 [It's Dead, Jim]

That may be so
But you just said that Mafia is likely to be less involved than Mafia

No. Most games with Werewolves see many citizens and only a power role or two. Most games with Mafia have citizens, but several more power roles on both sides.

Theyā€™re exactly the same
The roles have different names
Setups arenā€™t based on theming theyā€™re based on who think what roles work best where

1 Like

(( JammySplodge is right. The only real difference between Mafia and traditional Werewolf is thematic. Roles have an equivalent in both, e.g. seer and cop/detective or werewolf and mafioso. ))

(( You want even more people saying the same thing in an organized manner? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mafia_(party_game) has got you covered. ))

Iā€™m fully aware that there is a theme difference only

But, the way most of these games [keyword: most] end up being structured is very different. Sure, you can give the Werewolf faction allies that have different powers, and sure, you can keep the Mafia entirely Goons, but thatā€™s not how it usually works out.

(( My apologies for my misunderstanding of the matter. This was literally the first time Iā€™ve ever participated in a more traditional Mafia/Werewolf game, whether on a forum or off. You definitely have more experience than I do, orangeandblack. Iā€™d think in the case of this particular game, though, that itā€™s a fairly typical lineup of roles for both Mafia and Werewolf, so in this case thereā€™d be an equal chance that something like this would happen, given this situation no matter the theme. But then againā€¦what would I really know about it in practice? ))

no problem lol

Anyways, woo inactive WWs

-yawn- well this is pointless

Itā€™s dead, jim

1 Like

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_GBGfqoprI_w1e56H--uIEK1D9-FeYHiPWAWBYg0xlU/edit?usp=sharing

wtf dead

Too many inactive people

No

wtf deadfrien

1 Like

Wakes up from deep-slumber, yawns, then walks outside.

Hey, uh, how long has it been, anyone die lately?

(By the way, this is Alexandrite, Count Dooku is more suitable for Medieval Times name-wise compared to Alexandrite.)

does this game get reset if so /join

Itā€™s been dead 3 months m8

ithought it would be closed if dead was all

The man has a point.

:frowning: sadā€¦

RIP

the best meme