It’s true that the likes of Alice can pass themselves off as town as naturally as us breathing.
Though those sort of players are rare, and if every town player makes an effort to chip in and get discussion going, that alone would ensure a lot less mislynches in the PoE.
I should also add one more comment in reply to Gorta’s post.
If townies made an effort to get out of PoE and not just lie down and die ala Wild West FM, then it’s much harder for wolves to escape the PoE and avoids town stomps as in Wild West FM.
I townlean Boss110 for this post. They basically read me in part on my profile picture, which is not that good, but it doesn’t feel fake. They also provide a more contrarian take on Biden, which I like.
Any experienced player is not going to quake from having 1/2 votes on them early day 1. I think my vote is still in a good spot.
I had similar thoughts on the Boss take with regards to the Biden point, so I feel better about this slot.
It’s more so a joke about your opening post and how you seems very eager to hunt wolves.
My point is, Biden is ignoring them completely and seems like they either don’t care or are just ignoring it. A wolf would care about their apperance and the discussion surrounding themselves more, not like this.
I am going to finish my read. Ping me or quote my post if you have a question.
I don’t think biden has really been outright wolfy in any way
I think tonally it’s ~fine and i’d be tempted to townlean the general bluntness if I didn’t lack knowledge of his wolfrange.
I think early reads without much reasoning are good but I don’t think are outright wolfy unless they are from somebody who you know can do more.
I have outright 
on Eli / TBE / Gorta, not just like PoE or people I think contain tons of wolves but people I want to focus.
Gorta should clear up if / when more posts from him come
Eli is someone who I don’t think deserves the townreads they’ve gotten and had 1 thing I found specifically wolfy so I want to put more pressure on that slot.
TBE is someone I do usually tunnel and I just like have not seen anything clearing from this slot so I want to force something out of a player who has generally seemed super comfortable.
I do still want to put people in uncomfortable positions and force them to make decisions or take stances that could be compromising as w.
I could post hentai but I think that would just get me banned so I have to think of something else
w/e
enough ramblings
if anyone has any ideas to make BIG GAMER FLASHY BOOM stuff happen lmk
Second time is not the charm.
Apprentice - I like his opening as you can see how his read and thought process develop as he read the thread, otherwise there’s nothing extreme to see. His read are good but too safe, as in, I want to hear his opinion on other players whose most people didn’t already read them more. Townlean for now.
Conroy - There’s always something interesting about Conroy’s post. Whenever I read it I can sense and experiencing emotions from them, which is a thing that you can feel in most of his post and it seems genuine. Otherwise he seems very self-aware which is questionable but the fact that he constantly reevaluate his read is something I believe come from town.
PKR - Putting the Light discussion aside because it’s NAI. PKR put Seth as a townlean-but-to-be-read-later is understandable, I like that he doesn’t jump on the “locktown Seth” immediately and still consider all possibility. His read on Marshal is also solid, with plausible reason. He is good for now, as I have no reason to scumread him but a reason to townread.
CRichard - Richard read are decent, and they’re always backed up by reason. Also actively engaging in other people read and adding their opinion to it as well as trying to start discussion. I put this as townlean but not higher than that, as I want to see Richard read on more people.
Marshal - Unlike other where I agree with most of their read, Marshal is a different case as
I agree with all of them. Marshal is, to quote him, is playing more of a “support” as show in his disinterest in pushing agenda and what not while also still share his thought and not immediately jump to a conclusion.
Merc - Mercenary is, to put it bluntly, picking target. She only interact with people when it’s either fluff, mechanic, someone she make a read on (noticeable Conroy) or when it’s regarding her. I want her to interact with others people and play less passively, as in, generating discussion or partake in one more rather than waiting for one.
Why.
Derp - Exicited for rolling town? Sound familiar. Read on Italy is a joke at best and meta at worst so let’s ignore that. His question on Marshal whenever he “is a wolf?” or not doesn’t seem to be leading anywhere from the look of it, so that’s something I am curious to hear more. All of his read is otherwise gut without any reason to it because it is, well, gut. Can’t say anything more here.
Wazza - How convenient it is that someone just claim (as a joke) and you first post is commenting on that, asking the question that is obvious. Also completely ignoring accusation on him by putting it as “is this a joke?”
Gorta - Opening post is a combination of joke and nullread, either that or a consensus townread without providing any reason. Right now, he seems to be busy and promise more read later. So let’s wait.
I don’t know what’s worse, the fact that it took me so long to finished this or that nothing happen despite me taking a lot of time.
People need sleep and that’s probably a good part why there isn’t much thread activity.
Don’t worry, it will pick up again.
I made one post and then left the thread when I realised that it wasn’t a good time to stay there. Others were talking about other things and whenever I enter the thread I’m usually at least asked a question about my reads and what not if the thread state isn’t in such a bad way as it was earlier.
Also, may I ask why you think that I would publicly state I’ve read claims and not just y’know, keep them in my classcard?
I don’t know why you’re agreeing with him. You’ve played with me before and you know how inactive I can be at times. While it’s different this game since I want to contribute, I just haven’t as the thread state hasn’t been in a good way since when I entered and we both know about this. Honestly, if you’re agreeing with him then you’re clearly a suspect in my eyes as you know how I play. I don’t know who Foley is but he probably should read one of my games or get a TL;DR on them at least.
Also, may I ask, what’s stopping me from lurking in the thread and using that claim as a way to enter the thread. As I’m sure most people are aware I don’t just join the thread with nothing to say as that immediately leads to a fluffpost.
While it was a coincidence that I entered at that point (Since I was busy with Among Us things as y’know I do a lot), you are aware on how I play. This post against me isn’t looking very good in hindsight and just seems like a scum agreeing with someone elses read and has no absolute clue what they’re talking about at this point.
How is that me agreeing with Foley? I never said it is right or wrong. Just that I don’t like your respond when you can give a more proper answer.
Yes and no. I have played with you, that is correct, but how long was that ago? I don’t plan on using meta this game because it have been an age since I played mafia and I am gonna be honest that I forget meta of most players here, beside, I assume most players have change their meta anyway.
I missed like 500+ post and I didn’t have any problem entering the thread. You have nothing to say? Backread the thread and say your thought as you read it. Sound boring? ISO someone you find interesting from a quick glance and see what you can find. Doesn’t sound like your type still? Ask for a summary and start interacting with people who is currently online. Personally, I am lazy most of the time so I can relate a little but I am sure there’s a lot other way to enter the thread than… well, that.
- I don’t scumread people who only have two post, usually.
- See above. I never said I agree with Foley.
- What’s stopping town from agreeing with someone else?
- I may have no clue on what I am talking about, yes, and that’s where you and other come in. To disprove my point with reason, and I will say, you are not convincing me.
You literally stated the same exact thing as Foley did. That is literally directly agreeing with me.
a few months ago when my inactivity spiked.
Fair reasons but never avoid meta. I don’t know why people tell you too, there’s a select few people you can read based on meta.
You entered a thread with literally no other players, thus no topic to interrupt.
When I entered the thread there was so many people talking along with a claim which was the best thing to use when entering the thread. I never said I had a problem entering the thread in this game, I said previous games. All I specifically said was ‘What’s stopping me’.
I’ve already read the thread, I ain’t going to say my thoughts on said thread as I don’t think repeating already said things is very helpful.
That’s what I’m doing right now and interacting with you, nice to meet you.
well that was the best way and you can’t tell me otherwise.
k
See above. You clearly did.
Town who know something is factually incorrect proceeding to agree with it is a different story.
Yes you have no clue what you’re talking about and no my point is not to convince you as I just stated I don’t see you as a member of the Town.
How is this the exact same thing? Foley’s reason on you was that you were keeping tabs on claim (which according to you is a coincidence) but didn’t do anything else. Mine however was that you specifically choose to respond to a joke claim (N0 WHITEcheck) with such a bad question. (“Did you just claim” well, yes. If he didn’t claim you won’t be making this question, right?)
Is also not the exact same thing. As I am questioning why you didn’t give him a proper answer if you know well that he don’t know your meta.
I think I stopped playing FM for longer than that, not sure.
Or you can just read them the other way.
Nothing is stopping you. But I expected you to have a better question to ask that will lead somewhere.
Yeah, I can understand the last part. I would still like to hear your thought on thing which people haven’t reach an agreement on yet, though.
Nice to meet you too.
I am telling you otherwise right now.
I don’t think so.
Try to convince me or other here on why I am not town then.
I’m too lazy to dissect this quote properly.
You stated what he scumread me for and then scumread me for it. That’s the same thing.
Second part is confusing, no clue wtf you mean with the ‘you won’t be making this question’ because no shit sherlock.
I didn’t give him an answer as his point seemed ridiculous to literally anybody the point would be for, even without knowing metas.
But why would you want to take away a way of reading a player? Some people are so dumb, why would you remove a way of seeing a person as Town.
Why would it lead somewhere? Your expectations are too high for me.
Maybe later when there’s more people in the thread and not just us two.
, highfive.
Then, if you were in my shoes, how would you have entered the thread directly after a player fakeclaimed?
once again you were there at the time.
why would I convince you, the player who knows their own classcard, that you are not Town?
I am not even scumreading you as I said before. And if I am scumreading you, then I am using my own reason as it’s different from Foley.
As for the second part, I don’t know why you are asking someone if they claim or not right after they claim their class because duh.
How is his point ridiculous? He said that you didn’t do anything else and show your disinterest in solving, which seems normal to me.
Yes, that is true, but meta can change and it can be unreliable. Also, I never said that meta is not allow. I am just saying that I won’t use meta because I don’t know any.
Maybe you can make him contradict his claim or something, I don’t know, anything that is not already obvious.
I count as two and as such there’s three of us here now. What is your thought?
“Why did you claim your class BRUH. Please tell me you have a reason.”
Play along like the claim were real.
“This shit is wack yo, cut it out.”
My memory is bad and meta change.
So I can press the surrender button.
For real though, if you don’t think that I am town then isn’t it logical that you should try to convince other why that is the case.
I’m just gonna stop arguing with you on this matter now, there’s no point in continuing it.
It was very obviously a rhetorical question.
I made one post on day one and it’s being scumread because apparently that’s a ‘lack of solving’ commenting on what was going on at the time and leaving.
And once again, I also say to include Meta not rely on it.
okay now I’m confused.
I’m confused how you count as two and I don’t care either.
these are bad examples of what to say. mine was better.
nice, you’re French.
I’ll convince them when they’re here.