basically everyone who’s been scumreading him has mysteriously dropped dead
Counterpoint: he got motivated when I (a villager) talked to him, and demotivated when he is consistently being shot down.
I think the first point is extremely bizzare coming from scum.
No.
Saying that Nuclear died because he suspected Insanity is absurd.
Nuclear stopped voting Insanity and he even had a reason for it. He even said he could see Insanity flip town.
I actually feel Marshal is pushing bullshit.
I assume that someone here have a killing ability because this is technically a group full of assassin so you can say I am just asking for them. I myself may or may not have killing ability but it won’t hurt to ask. After all, we are supposed to work together
Also Insanity was already going down if scum.
Who would care to kill someone who suspects them.
They’d care if Nuclear suspected some other scum, maybe.
not just nuclear
Arete was just freaking D1 early kill, and probably for role reason.
And Marshal is using that flip still to this point. It’s nonsensical to me, and level 0 imo.
people have said that arete never claimed anything about their role or flavor
do you think mafia just randomly go around checking people’s roles
You talk like the entire mafia is concerned only with people suspecting Insanity for some reason.
When he would be the lowest mafia in their pack.
What are the odd of most scum lurking since right now town is lynching each other so they don’t want to interfere?
okay
for real here
what mafia would never think twice
what mafia would immediately take an action
what mafia would do the least expected thing
this can give us a PoE on this suspected “mafia rolecop”
How else do you check if you have rolecop on N0/early D1?
I think Arete was kill solely because he is a strong player
I think only half mafia at most are lurking.
But I don’t get a good feeling about the game tbh. So it’s probably worse.
That could be a factor, sure.
i find using such an ability at completely random at D1 would be too random for it to be sane mafia
thankfully we’re in a mash and so we have plenty of sanity lacking candidates like me
I think Arete is a good target to check IMO
checking a person’s role for the social reason that they are a powerful town
Not like they have a better target