…
What if doesn’t define the game.
I can think of MANY REASONS, WHY KNIGHT SHOULDN’T GET RETRIBUTION.
2 knights mislynched gg bd. nice try.
1 Like
Then how else would you prevent knights from being easily exed? It shouldn’t be confirmable, and people don’t do your other solution.
That’s the problem. You don’t give someone a gun. Say it could be a fake gun. and then let them shoot themselves.
I agree, but a lot of BD classes are already confirmable, and you can’t really change that without completely reworking them(and the only one which needs a rework is noble. The recent maid spy changes made its confirmability worse). Unless you add more easily claimable classes, which would be great.
You really went too far with this. BD is not the Conly faction that have investigators. The thing is all your argument came from your perspective and including only bad scenarios. And relying only on subjective opinions is usually very bad idea in the long run since it’s simply one-sided.
For example the author. He registered less than hour ago, and first post is: “Hey Devs change this into this ty” without caring about opinions of other people. How the Devs suppose to improve their game when they don’t know what’s the actual problem is?
With playerbase’s current midset giving Retribution to Knight wouldn’t change a thing. The only thing that
we would accompish is BD getting more punished because of their stupidity.
It doesn’t confirm the CS target is scum if there was no physician/alchemist on the knight, because the target could have been NK/MM/Scorned/Fool and the knight could have been killed simply through other sources. This would happen more often than you think, because the knight tends to CS suspicious targets, whereas scum is actively killing BD. Also the knight can only CS after a certain period, so more members are dead already (usually not the NK/MM/Scorned/Fool). So BD needs to work together to obtain this powerful interaction, with 2 largely unconfirmable BD classes. Sounds perfectly balanced to me.
As a Knight, add to the conversation, claim early to either King or court in order to prevent being executed for a late Knight claim, and learn to townread and scumread and use your abilities accordingly. For an added bonus put your number on your DN so if you end up killing an evil you’ll be confirmed as Knight.
As an evil, stop claiming Knight. Because so many evils, Reapers and Assassins mainly, are claiming Knight then just claiming the role is guaranteed to bring on suspicion to yourself.
Thread-wise I approve of this change as aside from removing omniscient abilities, this should remove the “CS to prove that you’re a Knight” part. As a long-time ToS player, I can see the reasoning for CS not killing an ally, but on the other hand it makes Knights practically a no-risk class.
2 Likes
forever tricked…