Last Poster Before Threadlock gets a cookie (cookie thread v2)

mafia is not a game where people can get along. period.
it’s a competetive game because that’s where the fun comes from

They also take forever to design and requires players to host.
cries in my mash being designed for a larger playerbase

BOATS GOOD

whoooo boats

you have to appreciate the balls it took to put an event in a 60p that could potentially kill 16 people at once

Did you never see “perfect games”, where only scum died, and there wasn’t even a dead BD in the nights?

boatnoises

2 Likes

Meh, I think it’s that Priestess isn’t factoring the randomness when it comes to reads.

Like, for ToL/ToS is basically X has a confirmed heal, so he’s 100% Doc.

In FM you basically analyze who is most likely V and most likely W and then go on from there. There’s less certainty involved.

3 Likes

I said ‘very very rare,’ not ‘literally impossible’

What are boats?

I purposefully phrased it this way so it can be taken out of context.

confirmed angels are a dumb idea tbh

I don’t like competetive games, so I don’t get any fun from
And I don’t play FM anymore, which is kinda a good consequence from this

It happens, but it’s rarer than a NK win, and that’s saying something.

2 Likes

and quite frankly, I see a lot more BD losses in ToL due to BD being reluctant to execute when they might be wrong (even when a player was really suspicious) than BD losses due to players being executed for “bad” reasons

once i had an unseen win where BD didn’t kill the wrong player ever

NK wins are like 15-20%, so yea

then once again
why are you still here, and arguing for your version, when nobody else likes it?
i’ve never got a straight answer on this

‘so we have a Maid claim with three nights of straight matches, who didn’t defend their previous night’s match at all when they were on the stand, and didn’t vote up the Assassin when we executed them earlier’

‘WHY ARE YOU EXECUTING JUST BECAUSE THEY’RE A MAID, YOU ARE EVERYTHING WRONG WITH THIS GAME’

1 Like

which indicates how bad the BD players are, so your ultimate vision of Fun™ doesn’t even happen in the game you actually play

Less mechanical confirmation means social reads become more important. Which is what makes FoL quite different from ToL.

Indeed