here’s me forcing you to remember that there was a game where a memelord prince openclaimed day 1, missed 4 jails, wasted two executes on an empty cell, and proceeded to survive to day 10 carrying the game for town
Still regretting a bit to have mercilessly lynched Possessed after he replaced in, for the scumminess of his previous slot
But reevaluationg people after replacement gives an unfair advantage to that slot, so it’s better not to
Instant reaction tests are dumb ways of doing this and shouldn’t be allowed
But sometimes, this happening subconsciously is inevitable, if the person who just entered the slot has a more obvious meta and/or more WiM than the person who just left it.
That’s why I’m a fan of the new replacements policy; hopefully that will help to minimize this problem over time.
It’s not (solely) about reaction testing
It’s about discouraging strategic replacements
People often replace out when they get heavily scumread, and the replacer manages to be way more towny