weird timing for a Dat readlist 
Town(in order):
-
Astand- So yeah this was my check last night, not much to say bout it showed up town, was pretty null on him day 1 so I checked him. Woke up around when the end of Day 1 so I could snag the hammer that way I could get a second check and hopefully get a redcheck, that would have helped with my current predictament more where i dont have the greatest amount of time, but by the time I woke up turned out hammer was reached. Canāt really blame Hja for doing my plan except she was successful.
-
Andrej- Most improved and even though its not much I see him trying to make reads, and this is way different compared to MGS. This has to be town without a doubt.
-
chiangsmokers- Our Parity cop, even though I was sus of him early Day 1, when he claimed it felt natural to me. I hope he comes back with a redcheck for us, but we will have to wait I guess
-
Hippolytus- Legit have been liking this man, he feels apart of thread constantly unlike Ritual Mafia. Dont know if I trust the masons per say cause the team memesky interactions day 1 didnt feel like they were masons but thats prob just me
-
Vulgard-
Townlean:
-
Alice- So like why didnt she shoot, she didnt feel she need to, does that make her scum, no. Is it why she is a lean now compared to just town yes. Does the toxicity make her scummy, no. She did the same thing Swords and Staffs as town.
-
Firekitten- The confidence I saw in thread has diminished, I want to beleive FK is town cause my gut screams it, but has he really done much noā¦ Gonna keep him here due to Gut-o-nomics for now
-
Arete-
-
Simon- I made an ISO, go read it. It fits meta, even though he hasnt brought the much to the table imo
-
MaximusPrime- He always seems lost when entering thread which means hes prob not informed by scummates, but has some bad reads like shooting Andrej if he got the vig. But I kinda wish he went and pushed more
Yeah I know coming from me
Null:
- H_Hja
- Evil_Ginger- High Poster, low content, couldnā tell ya a single thing hes really done this game. But idk hes seems comfortable in thread,
- Icibalus
- Marshal
Scumlean:
- PoisonedSquid
- SetToBlow
- Universal
- SirDerpsALot
this is where im at so far, plus alice asked for reads
I kind of donāt want a greencheck on Astand running around, I want to be able to mislynch him at some point ideally soon and with a greencheck we wonāt be able to
Also I reallllly donāt like this line in the context of us intentionally trying to get a fake redcheck from him
and you can potentially say you checked her because of that dumb hammer ploy, if youāre āclaimingā
@Dat youāre hedging on every single read in there and thatās a bad thing
try to fix that, I can help you
1 Like
example
overexplainy especially since youāre gonna claim a greencheck.
better version:
Astand - town, got a greencheck on him last night. figured i should check him because vulās tunnel was a thing and overall he hasnāt been very town-motivated. he game up green so sheep him today
something along these lines. though I donāt agree with astand being your greencheck; from a town perspective, outing that just makes him a more likely claimvig target considering he hardclaimed. keeping the greencheck hidden as town would be the better play because it doesnāt give astand 100% confirmability and allows scum to keep him around
1 Like
better version (i think):
chiang - i think heās town. hardclaimed very easily and it felt natural. if he was scum heād know thereās a claimvig and how it works. hardclaiming a parity cop from a town perspective would get him shot, so he wouldnāt do it. if he wouldnāt figure that out by himself his scumbuds would tell him. basically, heās just town because of how heās been acting. still waiting for him to pop in with results.
iām using my personal wording because i donāt think i could convincingly replicate the way you phrase things, i donāt even know you that well.
just trying to convey an idea here of how town should make its reads. basically remove all the hedging and sound confident.
townies are wrong on reads all the time. itās not a bad thing if none of your scumreads are town on a readlist unless thereās something egregiously incorrect like scumreading a consensus or confirmed town.
hippo - heās been meming but he stays involved and is confident in his reads. i donāt sense agenda from him and he keeps the game going. iād take another look if he mislynches a bunch of people but heās always there and it doesnāt feel like heās trying to nudge the town into the wrong direction. unlike ritual mafia where he was scum and didnāt get involved, here heās doing something completely different. hard townread from me and you can fight me.
should I go on or do you get what iām saying
iām sure you can do it ily birdie boy
1 Like
fk - gut says town but it feels like he hasnāt done jack this game and itās d2. people have been saying i was dwindling but fk is also dwindling, itās just less noticeable because he posted more. iām still keeping this as a townlean but thereās a limit to my gutreads
you donāt need to evoke the same ideas as the ones iām evoking with these examples, you just need to remove hedging and be confident as hell
also itās a good thing youāre gonna post your readlist now because itās gonna look good that youāre moving the game in the right direction. the way i spun the thread itās all about alice and her behavior, youāre gonna offer a different perspective
ā¦Wait, if Alice is a PGOizer, then why the hell isnāt Marshal dead? Did FK protect him or something?
she might only shoot attackers
the way she said it iām pretty sure thatās how it works
which means itās AWESOME we didnāt nightkill her