Mafia Championship Season 8 - RESULTS ARE IN! (post 464)

Forum Matches Discussion
#422

I voted for you. I don’t know how you didn’t make it past the 1st stage.

1 Like
#423

I suspect people didn’t actually read how that stage worked

which is sad in its own right but multiple of you have said as much itt so

#424

might I mention that’s not a problem we’ve had any of the other times we’ve run champs voting

#425

It’s ridiculously time consuming and useless.
But we, I suppose someone decided, needed the stage to look like we’ve professionally picked someone.

#426

“orange”

#427

fptp is objectively dumb and it takes no extra time on any of your parts to run a better voting method

1 Like
#428

It’s not fptp if we can choose as many as we want but shrugze

#429

oh I see

why didn’t we just skip to the 2nd stage??

#430

lmao

#431

like I’m sure there is some sort of sophisticated formula to enable multiple ranked choice to give us a 1st and 2nd choice

#432

yes that’s how ranked choice works

#433

anything other than this useless 1st stage that’s just telling the people who didn’t even manage to get past the 1st stage false hope
the nominations are enough to filter out meme candidates
poor sulit

#434

they literally aren’t because you just need to be nominated and accept

also I don’t see how somebody not making it past the 50% stage is somehow “false hope” what

#435

literally the only things I changed were

  • making first-stage-of-voting results hidden
  • having a single method for second-round votes rather than ‘just do seven methods and hope they agree’

I do actually think the first change made people less likely to make it past the cutoff, but

#436

almost certainly true

#437

not sure how I feel about only certain people knowing how people voted but I don’t not see why you did that either

#438

I mean if I had a system that allowed for all three of:

  • no one including me knows who voted for what
  • we know who made it over the 50 percent cutoff
  • people can’t just cheat and vote multiple times

that would be preferable

there’s not a trivial way to do all three of those

1 Like
#439

they first need to be nominated and then win in the ranked choice vote
and if they get voted in the ranked choice vote that’s democracy:tm: and there isn’t anything you can complain about because enough people voted for them

through a quick google search I like the borda count

#440

this is impossible without individual codes being sent to people as an ‘allow to vote’ entrance thing
you can’t do this by IP anymore bc VPN avaliability
…
which a discord bot could do

#441

i was going to write something here but i dont think anything i say will be constructive

1 Like