Well to me I think scorned should stay (but LOSE trollbox), just on the basis that won scorned isn’t a bad desperation claim for an evil, and that should be left as a possibility. The keeping the trollbox to me was the exact oposite of a good idea… the only good reason a scorned should stick around IMO is the doubt that exists of “was he really a scorned or is that just a really good cover for some other evil”. Trollbox gives wonned scorned the aiblity to self confirm… which is just silly to me.
Inq though, never is a good fake claim as it’s unique and only appears with sorc.
Now as far as “having fun”, it’s less about that, and more about their ability to chose a winner. normally if you perfectly accurately manage to figure out a class, you know their win condiiton, and can have a decent idea of what they are trying to do. Even an alchemist you can make assumptions of what they will and won’t do. Say an alchemist is unlikely to do actions that are likely to get them executed or attacked. As a result the living players can work with that, threaten or offer support to the alc to get him to do what they want etc… A living alc is a wildcard, but he is one that can be anticipated in some way, as well as manipulated.
A won inq though, he could totally kill 3 cultists, he could intentionally stab the confirmed psychic and paladin back to back, and neither is strategically better or worse than eachother, because neither has any connection to his already completed win condition.
