[Minimash] Community Forum Mafia 2 - (5/9/31) - Game Over - ModeShifter (Alice) Wins!

Forum Matches Completed
#7257

He knew he was going to die, so it wasn’t a dayvig. If it was then he’d have reacted differently.

#7258

Light says Marshal is ‘positive’, although I don’t know what that exactly means unless he’s comparing a match with Hippo from day ability.

#7259

I guess that’s possible. Though I never got the impression that Hippo was a consensus town read D1.

#7260

That is not true.

#7261

I mean if Mafia had the day ban ability, why not use it on a more obvious town read such as Marshal?

1 Like
#7262

That’s why I said I don’t know what that exactly means, PKR.

You saw Light visiting Marshal then what’s the problem?

#7263

Re-reading Nap’s interactions rn.

Feeling better regarding Kyo by now. So far his posts with Kyo don’t look W/W in the slightest.

Nap literally just said this to Solic with no follow-up whatsoever. Probs would still kill Solic.

#7264

When L1ght said ‘positive’ he was saying his role was +EV instead of -EV (Whatever this means (I think EV stands was Extraordinary Villager?))

Then L1ght claimed the ability which was investigative… which does not make sense to do on Marshal.

#7265

Hippo literally said that “like my post and I’ll suicide.”

Like, he knew he could suicide and then decided to do it.

1 Like
#7266

Furthermore, L1ght’s claim suggests there are more day banners.

#7267

I think it’s more he pick his first target from someone who was banned while it’s day phase and night phase a living player

#7268

If so… then he didnt quite explain it well.
But gotcha.

#7269

So it’s quite possible Hippo killed himself so Marshal died? Well the plot thickens.

#7270

What does this mean…?

#7271

The way you’re making is sound, CRich is as if Hip was a delayed suicide bomber.
As ‘Hip killed himself so Marsh died’
That logically should be 2 separate incidents but you’ve just tried to link them

#7272

…this all is literally just speculation that’s been clogging the thread for no reason at all.

Here’s what we know.

  1. Hippo knew he was going to die so he likely used an action to kill himself.
  2. According to ob Hippo and Marshal are different alignments.
1 Like
#7273

I’m trying to describe the scenario you talked about in my own words PKR.
Mind you I think I butchered it.

#7274
  1. According to Kyo there are no neutrals/third party.
    Thus it would suggest Hippo and Marshal were Mafia v Town should both be telling the truth.
#7275

That doesn’t explain the positive result from two of them together

#7276

…and do you believe ob is telling the truth?