If you could sort of summarise the posts which make you townread him thatd be much appreciated. From his play yesterday I very much scumread him and townread you which which makes me question that either I am very wrong or you are very wrong.
I am often very wrong but am fairly confident this time so would love for you to perhaps read back your private conversations with him and consider the possibility of him being evil.
Perhaps this is why you are still alive? You are pocketed by him thus evils dont fear you? (Actually Iām unsure of killing mechanics this game. Can evils kill at night? If not this last point can be ignored. If they can, why was there no death last night.)