i don’t really care, i find the pdf I have to be strictly better that the information tan wrote in the old thread’s OP
but yes, Outisders are members of the town like any other, unless they are mentioned specifically, like with fang gu
Please use good rather than town to refer to the good team
If you say town, that causes confusion with townsfolk
i disagree. using the word town to refer to the good team can cause a lot of confusion with the townsfolk sub category
you have an opinion as to what it should be acceptable to refer to good as other than good
that i disagree with
Simon feels like a villager to me, perhaps for a silly reason. He has been more than ready to engage in arguments with people I consider villagers, and putting himself “out there” like this from the start of the game would be a very bold strategy as a wolf. Besides, I don’t think there is a good reason for a wolf to keep arguing with people early on, especially over little things which do not matter. Simon’s insistence on keeping up these discussions feel to me like the instinct of a stubborn villager.
I may flip this read, because I can still see a wolf doing this, but I believe in a villagery motivation. Simon is now several steps closer to my lock villagers.
I had a couple of thoughts about other players, but I don’t really believe them. Please start posting something that will help me sort you out.
Walks out of the thread.
I’ve already claimed, and my info is all out there so Simon saying “if you don’t claim a strong role we are just going to kill you”
is from a scum that hasn’t been absorbing the information happening around him
That’s not what I’m saying.
I’m saying that if your not a strong role, it’s okay for you to be lynched
As in, the lynching becomes not a penalty, or at least less of one
I honestly don’t know your info, your right that I missed it or something. But lynching the easy claims day 1 just makes sense in BotC.
Like in another mode for BotC, trouble brewing, one of the n1 only roles is usually lynched d1, because they’re really easy to take, and of all town to lynch, they provide the least possible punishment toward town (besides the fact that a town was lynched instead of an evil, there is 0 punishment)
I’m not going to correct myself, sorry. I’m specific enough in my word choice for an arbitrary rule as to what means what, as a filter, to work,
Aka, if you give me an arbitrary message of mine from BotC I can tell you with a significant degree of assurredness what I meant
When I say townsfolk, I mean the group of roles labeled townsfolk, and the people within the game whose roles are within that group. Repeat for outsiders, minions, demon/demons
When I say scum, evil, etc. I mean a person that is within the latter two groups.
When I say good, town, or bd, I mean a person that is within the former two groups
When I say a towny, I mean a person that appears to be within the former two groups.
When I say a scummy person (or equivalent. This one does not have a particular term for me), I mean a person that appears to be within the latter two groups
This is almost always the case, and when it isn’t, I almost always provide a clarification. If I ever do not, it is a mistake on my part and I apologise for that
1 Like
