(Misc) Blood on the Forums III: Moonlight Badness (Good Wins)

Forum Matches Completed
#4986

Could you tell everyone to ignore me Cheese? I think Light blinded me to the truth. He isn’t minstrel. He’s the demon. My theory is that the GF attacked Winter N2 which got rid of his protection against dying. It makes perfect sense if you think about it. Otherwise there would’ve been a death that night. He then took that opportunity to claim Minstrel.

#4987

*unignore

#4988

there is no redemption arc

#4989

Because I hadn’t communicated with anyone aside from basically consensus town through whispers, so killing myself would be completely undiscussed with my scumbuds

Which would mean potential noticeable concern

#4990

@everyone
unignore
at least acknowledge they exist once in a while

Sadly this won’t explain you dying if you’re actual fool.
You’re lockscum, no matter what.
Sorry buddy.

#4991

I’ve already painted this out
Unless Amelia was GF that suicided last night, sacking TBE today wins town the game (MM can extend game past F2 according to tan). From my PoV there are only three possible options; they are below:

#4992

There can be. I think the scum are Kyo, Magnus, Amelia, and Light. With Light as the demon.

#4993

Actually, yes it would if Winter was attacked N2.

#4994

Thanks Cheese.

#4995

Note that my plan to have derps kill everyone through the shacklewight group was thoroughly discussed between us in BotF IV and was also basically necessary for us to win given the gamestate at that point

So the conditions for me killing myself as GF and putting the entire town’s neck on cheese are pretty different, as I remember you mentioning BotF IV N

#4996

all GF kills have been accounted for (1 kill after Arete Death, Amelia kill this night)
all Po kills have been accounted for (1 kill after Arete Death, the triple kill)

none of those targetted winter
if assassin exists then the death would’ve killed winter

#4997

You could be lying about the light message and he could have passed what u said on to everyone else

But that theory is kind of bad since your only whisper with him ever was during day 1.

#4998

(i doubt you would be able to see the future and have a death wish in that regard)

#4999

Tell me if my scenario of Winter getting attacked by GF N3 is even possible to explain why I didn’t survive the lynch as fool.

#5000

We didn’t execute an outsider D2

So impossible

#5001

:frowning:

#5002

there’s actually a funny world where light could be real minstrel who stopped DA leafia from self protecting
but what are the odds of that happening

no, really :eyes:

#5003

But then they would have made the triple kill not happen

#5004

…there’s actually a funny world where minstrel!light would mean that there would be no kills the night after Leafia died

#5005

you’re right