@Wazza
Oh also, I forgot to mention.
I can exile you when I’m dead too [quote=“Wazza, post:2801, topic:81065”]
This is why you are being lynched today:
- You are the best lynch, considering your ability is extremely useless and easily fakeable by scum.
- You are being pushed on by my Townreads/Townleans and pushing on my Townreads/Townleans.
- The way you acted at the very start of the game.
- Wanting to exile beneficial Travellers, one being me who is beneficial lategame but not beneficial early game.
- Rolefishing.
- Other Choices of Lynching are bad choices apart from killing Dat’s corpse but I doubt I can get Dat to kill himself.
Why I’m against lynching you:
- Confirmed not Demon by my Townread.
- Your pushing on me.
- The chance of you being Arete is high if you were Minion.
- There was another reason that I forgot due to getting distracted.
Make more points on why I shouldn’t lynch you.
[/quote]
Reasons for Lynching Me (Rebuttals)
-
My ability is pretty useless ngl. I think the “fakeable by scum” depends on how exactly the Kape claim distributes their information but it can be fake claimed. I disagree about being the best lynch because I’m not Demon.
-
I don’t have the same reads as you do. I’ve explained why. If you want me to I’ll quote the post where I explain why I’m pushing on your townreads/leans. I assume Alice is one of them? The only way for me to rebut this is to explain why I think your townreads shouldn’t be townreads.
-
You gotta elaborate more on this.
-
My vote to exile you was partially a reaction test on multiple ends (I might describe some other ends later). It was also partially out of annoyance to see if you would come up with something more concrete. I wanted to see how you would react. I don’t think your reaction was scummy tbh, though if it was I would continue to pursue it because a lot of your actions weren’t making sense. That doesn’t mean I’m letting go of my vote yet though.
-
I don’t remember any instances of my rolefishing tbh but I’ll tell you I don’t mind if people claim their class. It’s not easy for scum to take advantage of it - look at Hippolytus’ opener which I took into consideration. When I entered the thread, Geyde directed me towards it and so it was one of my first ISOs. Hence, why I felt comfortable open claiming briefly afterwards.
-
From an objective standpoint I can’t argue why Alice is a good lynch because I don’t know tbh. I can say that they haven’t felt townie. Also maybe DatBird is a wolf so who knows? But I’m town.
Other Reasons to Townread Me
- So I’ve been universally scumread amongst most tbh. What this means is that either Im a wolf who looks as if they are doomed, or I’m a LHF town. However, then Hippolytus comes and defends me - KyoDaz partially as well. Now, we aren’t seeing any other defenders to be honest. I personally read both of them as town because their progression seems to make sense. If they are town, then there aren’t any other doubts that have emerged yet, and even then Hippo/KyoDaz haven’t voiced an alternative lynch. This could have been an opportunity to save me; though I suppose that doesn’t mean much with you in the game; giving me voting power could be just as useful.
- Analyze my interactions and try and look at my PoV from both perspectives. I think a town one fits plausibly
- I’ve explained the thought process behind all my actions and most of my reads and posts. If you still feel uneasy with something, I’ll explain it.
Also:
I mean I can see where this assumption is coming from but why is it a reason not to lynch me?
I would think you were a townie tbh if you weren’t a Traveler but idk how you would play differently as a Lost Wolf (who only knows Demon) due to lack of meta so .
Logically my brain tells me I should die so I get a vote but my gut is telling me it’s a bad idea.