[quote=“Redrover1760, post:1326, topic:81065, full:true”]
I like actually. Sadly this wasn’t really followed up on.
He asks for my ISO first.
I feel like this may have been a slip that Napoleon screwed up something in the whispers. And Geyde said “go take a look at Datbird” and was simply calling attention to it instead of providing reads by Geyde, which is different from what he said later.
Null.
Geyde says he is pretty confident that DB is wolf so that’s notable. This ticks me off honestly. Not to mention the single townie thing. Its true, DB didn’t do much, but he’s basically calling him Scummy now.
I ask for Napoleon to ISO him and he doesn’t comply quickly so idk what he is thinking. I don’t care if you are God, you ISO or die.
Yes.
Yeah finally pls.
Yes.
This is fine.
Napoleon:
NAI
DatBird:
N.1:
N.1:
N.1:
Apprentice (Resident)
Hippolytus (Resident)
Mist1422 / Chemist1422 (Resident)
Redrover (Resident)
N.1:
Napoleon (Resident)
Geyde (Resident)
MukuroIkusaba / Alice (Resident)
Honestly just going down the list and gonna throw off gut vibes.
Im not caring about travelers at least until nom phase as of right now we kinda play by word them. Like Wazza decides execution and Italy lets N and Marshal pick with 1 being confirmed to be opposite allignment with more being also an option, so we go by looking at the noms closely and see how much town core they are. Amelia kinda randomly used two of their three uses for some reason and if they didn’t change me as well I would have prob been modkilled since I didn’t read thread before messaging back to my neighbor who was asking for reads, as I assumed I would still be next to him. So as a word of warning catch up first from now on. Katze and Icis class I have 0 clue on and will ask for others to inform me on how they work as this setup is a lot from a person who barely played the second one.
As for just gut vibes on non travelers Redrover posts just rubbed me in the wrong way. Priestess seems to be incapacitated at the time, so I will wait to hear more from them when they are feeling better. Hippo seemed very lost which is prob a good look for him. The rest were kind of non resistant from my skim
Removes travelers from the list because of not an initial read on them. I kinda didn’t like this but now I guess I understand it. Regardless, it’s nothing too meaningful atm.
Like they are repeating facts but not reaching too many conclusions.
DatBird:
As for just gut vibes on non travelers Redrover posts just rubbed me in the wrong way. Priestess seems to be incapacitated at the time, so I will wait to hear more from them when they are feeling better. Hippo seemed very lost which is prob a good look for him. The rest were kind of non resistant from my skim
DatBird:
So like my two main reads right now are that Im liking Hippos posts and Red Rovers Im not. Its mainly gut, I could prob go deeper and explain which posts if need be. Priestess didnt have much before they left, and everyone else kinda just was forgettable and thus thrown into null. Is there anyone in particular u want more of an opinion on? Other than a new game came out, im pretty open atm
Like overall it feels like his reads are pretty lazy and his conclusions are hard to make of. But why does he @DatBird ).
I wouldn’t normally scumread this but I’ve spent my last three games with this player and it has made an impression for me. I’ve been reluctant to scumread them based on activity as seen in Rokugan and Ice Cream before but now they are exhibiting similar behavior and if they are scum, I’m not letting them slide for a third time
Speaking of which, hi Datbird.
Removes travelers from the list because of not an initial read on them. I kinda didn’t like this but now I guess I understand it. Regardless, it’s nothing too meaningful atm.
Ah, so of course, Datbird didn’t do a single townie thing right? Yeah that’s not townie at all. And you were the one talking about how you didn’t want to ISO for no reason. +Scum
This reliance on PMs is so weird honestly.
And so it begins.
Napoleon:
…
Napoleon:
???
Napoleon:
Answer my question pls
I’m not a wolf because:
I steered this conversation away from useless mech talk
I analyzed reads and evaluated them myself. My initial reads were actually Hippo town and Amelia town (which I had discussed with Geyde in PM; Geyde agreed with Amelia but disagreed with my analysis with Hippo, I think they took it as null. Their logic weakened my townread on Hippo but still slight V)
If you believe that Geyde and I were PMing, it makes little sense as Minions would have a scum chat that’s usable at day (I assume this, check OP, they can’t communicate at night tho).
Which means that this was orchestrated by us in scumchat (if you think W/W, consider the possibility of the use of PM vs scumchat)
I am Kape and I told you that: “Arete’s keyword doesnt start with a vowel”. An early-game claim could be done as scum, but I’ve pretty much been open with this so far.
Why have I been PMing? I guess I just like a small enclosed neighbourhood as it tends to be better at revealing peoples’ true thoughts in an environment where people might feel more secure.
Argument A: What do you even mean. Useless talk outside of 100% fluffing does not exist.
Napoleon:
Napoleon:
I’m not a wolf because:
I steered this conversation away from useless mech talk
I analyzed reads and evaluated them myself. My initial reads were actually Hippo town and Amelia town (which I had discussed with Geyde in PM; Geyde agreed with Amelia but disagreed with my analysis with Hippo, I think they took it as null. Their logic weakened my townread on Hippo but still slight V)
I am Kape and I told you that: “Arete’s keyword doesnt start with a vowel”. An early-game claim could be done as scum, but I’ve pretty much been open with this so far.
Why have I been PMing? I guess I just like a small enclosed neighbourhood as it tends to be better at revealing peoples’ true thoughts in an environment where people might feel more secure.
N.1:
There is NO scum chat. Players may communicate only in the public thread or via whisper. If you whisper someone that is not your neighbor, there will be a record of that having occurred in the public thread for the entire game, so be careful if you’re evil to stop easy associations based on whisper patterns from being made.
I probably worded this poorly but I think my point still stands. What do you think we’ve been talking about in our PM? How to lynch DatBird together? On our reads of others?
Answer this pls lol
I actually didn’t read anything this game. I mistook the meaning for my own role.
Your point now claims you are talking about your reads of others? I’m confused.
I can’t expand my arguments if you don’t make sense or tell me what to expand on, or listen to me.
Napoleon:
Geyde influenced my reads but I agreed with him that DatBird looked scummy there and I decided to make the push myself.
Maybe I should have waited for Geyde to voice his thoughts but:
This mechtalk wasn’t getting us anywhere and now I gave everyone on this thread something to analyze.
This dismissal of “Mechtalk” is so weird.
This is what you want my thoughts on y/n
