[Misc] Blood on the Forums V: Ides of Blood - Good Wins!

Forum Matches Completed
#2324

Are there worlds in which Ghana/Arete are evil?

#2325

If there are we are fricked either way

#2326

No

Old theory is for l0oser

New theory is tan effigy, Magnus eclipse and Whysper retro

#2327

anyways I need to go have dinner

#2328

Good luck nerds

#2329

Also GGhana pushed for Siulvui"s execution day 1, which is an odd move by minion considering how Light was gonna be killed?

#2330

wouldn’t the demon want wicked to live?

#2331

Well yes. But also there’s a couple problems. Which would be keeping Light alive in the first place long enough so that he gets converted.

Now… it’s possible Arete/Silvui could be the demon, but then why would GGhana ever push to get their own demon executed.

It GGhana was the Demon, that would mean he is Retro… and that would take 2 nights. Also he has been seen as “Minion” twice. And that would mean Cloned isn’t poisoned by being the Clockhand on his result
of Whysper.

Furthermore, Whysper has seen Cloned as evil night 3 which is ???

#2332

think about it, if Ghana is demon you save the wicked and then control the board to leave bad info, which gets us in confusing messes like this

#2333

Well yes… but then 4… 5 people actually? Are poisoned then

#2334

and I just realized that this isn’t possible because we executed Ghana

#2335

Wait what we did?

#2336

Ghana was yesterday’s execution

#2337

Wut

#2338

Am I hallucinating? I thought no one was executed yesterday?

#2339

no one was executed yesterday

#2340

GGhana is very much alive

#2341

OH, so my theory is still possible

#2342

Tan says GGhana minion (Ambusher), and that secondhand exists
PKR says GGhana minion
Cloned says Whysper retro night 2
Whysper says Cloned evil night 3
GGhana knows Cloned is good
Light claims Wicked
Magnus claims Chieftain, which supports Light Wicked claim
Gorta invited death every night, and knows that an ambusher exists.
Arete claims clockhand good N2 and N3

3 of thse are lies.

Things I am not willing to reconsider:
Light is Wicked
I did find Whysper retro night 2
None of Tan, PKR, myself, or light are demons.
Whysper is not a demon.

Let us begin.
Magnus has claimed to be the Chieftain, and nobody has countered it. This means that they are one of {Chieftain, Effigy}, so no other roles can be effigy. Magnus has had no chance to trade claims before they claimed to be an outsider-affecting role.

Therefore, none of Tan, PKR, and myself are effigies.

I was clearly malfunctioning N2. What are the supporting evidence for me being the clockhand, meaning Intensify was the demon?

This explains:
Whysper getting evil me night 3
Arete’s claims
Tan + PKR seeing GGhana as minion, probably secondhand
Light being Wicked
Gorta knowing that ambusher exists
Magnus being effigy

:eyes:

#2343

what did intensify claim again