[Misc] Blood on the Forums V: Ides of Blood - Good Wins!

Forum Matches Completed
#1343

I literally told you my reasoning for why I thought it would be impossible for Effigy

#1344

Explain.

#1345

What? Wdym I never mentioned Effigy…

#1346

Why cant they be scum.

#1347

you mentioned it after i brought it up.

#1348

Because I didn’t consider the possibility that one of them could have been minion and only thought that people outside of those 2 could be minions

#1349

Like when I said “Light and Magnus are both confirmed?”

#1350

also i literally did not

#1351

Effigy*
I got them mixed up

#1352

at no point in that discussion did we even talk about an eclipse?

#1353

actually i pointed out that you spewed that there was no effigy, but we can play pretend sure

#1354

What.
Is me mixing Effifgy and Eclipse TMI now?

#1355

you still havent explained what an effigy has to do with whysper and cloned being poisoned.

#1356

alright i think at this point it is clear youre arguing in bad faith.

#1357

It was my reasoning for why I thought Effigy couldn’t exist. Since if it did exist, that would mean both Whysper and Cloned couldn’t be poisoned.

#1358

I have to go to an appointment @Arete you deal with this

#1359

again, still havent adequately explained this. I still dont understand it.

but i need to go so i’ll just stop.

#1360

Because 1 minion couldn’t have poisoned both of them

#1361

Whysper is the Demon, you and Tan are minions (maybe Gorta is a minion instead of Tan if someone’s malfunctioning), everyone else that I didn’t name is town

uh more seriously

  1. Tangeld - overall been reasonably townie but I know she can fakesolve as wolf and her perspective on Whysper is kind of inconsistent
  2. Arete - hi
  3. Light - townread based on Outsider claim (this counts as a social read because part of what I’m reading him on is how he handled the claim)
  4. an_gorta_pratai - null, slightly >rand V socially because he hasn’t whispered anyone except maybe his neighbors
  5. Magnus - probably town, the way he handled Light on D1 makes sense for the class he’s claiming
  6. Whysper - PoE
  7. clonedcheese - probably town but mostly because he’s dead
  8. Intensify - technically PoE but probably not the Demon based on EoD2
  9. PokemonKidRyan - very town, died N1 + D1 play lines up perfectly with his claim
  10. GGhana - probably wolf but mostly because of mech
#1362

uh this was in reply to Ghana’s ping post