[Misc] Blood on the Forums V: Ides of Blood - Good Wins!

Forum Matches Completed
#1423

Better question, if Whysper told me to do a role swap with her why wouldn’t she tell me how the role worked?

#1424

Sorry sweetie, too busy smashing ur dreams of a scum win

#1425

GGhana: ‘you haven’t managed to conclusively identify the exact role of every player in the game with 100 percent certainty so your solve doesn’t work’

also GGhana: refuses to name a mechanically possible three-person scumteam that includes the person he’s pushing

#1426

Because I’ve been too busy debating with you and intensify to solve the game?

I’ve given multiple reasons why your solve doesn’t work

uh oh stinky

#1427

…doesn’t that apply literally regardless of your alignments?

#1428

No. Because if she was my demon wouldn’t she want me to not fuck it up?

#1429

claimisdisputed

#1430

Why would tan try to shade Gorta of all people. The person who’s clearing her. Why would Whysper try to clear you. Why would our scum team be so uncoordinated even though me and Tan could whisper at any time.

#1431

okay but if she were town she would also want you to not mess it up

#1432

No she wouldn’t. Because she actually assumed I was competent

#1433

doesn’t apply because she didn’t have Gorta’s claim at the time, and therefore she didn’t know that he was clearing her

she probably chose Gorta because he was LHF and not widely townread

because Demon!Whysper had to clear someone and needed a check that made sense, in general it’s unlikely for a Demon to greencheck a Minion which limited her options somewhat

you don’t seem very uncoordinated, just kind of boxed in

#1434

so she’s planning on killing cloned that night, she doesn’t want to clear any minions. She knows you’re LHF but decides to clear you anyways

Yet tan doesn’t do the same? How strange.

#1435

She knew there was a blasphemer, soz

#1436

@GGhana

still waiting for a viable three-person scumteam that includes Intensify

I’m not asking you to commit to a definitive solve, just for you to propose three players and their roles such that your solve is (a) mechanically possible and (b) socially coherent

#1437

Honestly the worst thing about this bullshit is the only one that comes to mind includes whysper

#1438

Tan is … claiming a role that learns the identity of a Minion if they die … so no, she couldn’t really claim to greencheck someone …

#1439

what’s your evidence for this, if this is something that happened in whisper can I have the exact “chain” of information?

#1440

you’re saying that the scum are trying to look Townie, killing yourself to shade someone random who might end up confirming you does not follow this objective

#1441

also you seem to be ignoring that her dying made me look evil as sin

#1442

So answer me. Why are the minions bussing each other while the demon is clearing random people?