Do you want to have this fight again?
Alright you acted like it was impossible for there to be an effigy despite you mentioning them before which by itself isn’t damning. But then you based the assumption off that Whysper and cloned were poisoned but you yourself think they’re the demon
Yeah, so can I. The Demon is probably either Whysper or Intensify. I’m open to waiting to execute the former, so I can confirm them.
I re-read your push on Whysper and realized that you never actually put her at risk of dying and specifically avoided voting her
I was trying to come up with solves that made mechanical sense and Tan minion made a lot of mechanical sense, also her interactions (especially whisper history) made a fair amount of sense to be W/W with you + Whysper and I noticed that she was being kind of agenda-y in that every time I gave a reason for Whysper to be town she encouraged it and every time I gave a reason for Whysper to be scum she tried to shut it down
copypasting your night result? no that’s super sketchy and they shouldn’t have done it, that’s why I put it in small text, it was sort of a ‘wtf are they doing’ comment
basically here’s my logic
demon is probably either Intensfiy (which is why Arete is trying to save them so hard) Whysper (intensify and Arete are intentionally trying to distance badly so that they look evil while she looks good)
honestly if Arete is town and Whysper is the demon I will facepalm because all their shenanigans are making me try not to think about if they’re the demon out of pride.
you’ve proposed that it’s possible for Intensify to be Demon instead, and a couple people have basically said they have no idea what any of the mechanics stuff means
Huh???
What…
Ok so I’ve literally already explained the “ignoring Effigy” part or whatever 100 times already. I did not consider the possibility of Effigy because at the time I thought that would mean it was impossible for both Whysper and Cloned to be poisoned at the same time in that scenario since 1 minion couldn’t have possibly poisoned both of them.
Also what? Wdym I said it wasn’t damning?
I said they would be poisoned in THAT SCENARIO. Not actually me thinking that they are poisoned, since I think Whysper is demon still
Silviu -> Arete: slight scumread, they aren’t like how they were in the previous game I played with them. Arete does a bit to improve the slot, but I am want to look at this slot closer. I think Arete makes the slot a townlean, but I won’t clear them as quickly.
Whysper: I don’t know where I would rank Whysper if we are being honest. I have them as a null and don’t really see them super towny. Their claim also seems like it could be faked in my opinion.
PKR: townlean, I want to say PKR is a townlean for (a) solving and (b) dying at night. They also seem cool in the thread socially.
Cloned: semi null, this is a slot I want to look at closer when I am not tired as hell. On the surface they don’t have many memorable pushes, go over some mech stuff, and don’t really tell me they are lock clear based on posts.
Magnus: This is probably a bad read, but I am willing to clear them on posting alone. I want to say if they got scum here their WiM would be really low and thus they wouldn’t do much posting.
Intensify: I can’t explain it, but I kind of get bad vibes from Intensify. Maybe it’s that they called PKR Ambusher when I didn’t tell them that there was an Ambusher in the game, but I don’t know. I’ll give it a more detailed look later.
I made lazy man reads, but those are my current thoughts. I do want opinions on Intensify and I will cover Tan,Ghana, and Light later. I just need a break
I think at this point it’s time to bandage my pride and think about worlds where Whysper is scum.
I mean Whysper’s “hey guys, I’m diviner, the demon is X” could easily be scum leading the game with misinfo
What’s wrong with me mixing up Stalker and Ambusher. They all sound so similar in my head
