Cough cough the start of the game.
We’ve spent like the past 3 hours trying to convince you. It’s clear we literally can’t.
Of course you can’t.
Because I know I’m right.
I know i’m right, just like I knew I was right those games I guessed the evils literally first day.
Magnus the issue with your idea is
- you might die (which would prevent us from getting any info on Whysper)
- you might be malfunctioning (which would prevent us from getting trustworthy info)
- you might be evil, and intentionally cover for her (which would give us actively untrustworthy info, and potentially make it less likely for her to be executed if she actually is the Demon)
- unless there’s the possibility of Whysper being Good, there’s not really a benefit to not executing her
I’m willing to consider executing someone else today if and only if you can come up with a viable three-person scumteam that Whysper isn’t on
I won’t die, unless the Demon is an idiot.
There’s a limit to how malfunctions there can be this game, and the STs would have given me false info yesterday most likely if I were.
I know I’m not evil.
Are you saying that you would kill a Minion even if the Demon is objectively a better target?
killing a Demon is obviously better than killing a Minion but Whysper is … literally at the forefront of the Demon PoE
bear in mind that if three evils are still alive, we kill town, and one of the evils is a Secondhand (or Effigy) then Good loses
Well, yeah, but I doubt it.
Seriously.
Because she hasn’t been proactive enough to be Demon.
Hah, well, that’s not the only reason.
(I don’t like how I’m defending Whysper more than Whysper is herself, and you and Ghana are defending Intensify more than they had themselves.)
part of what I’m figuring out here is if I can trust you
the fact that you seem super insistent that Whysper can’t possibly be the Demon, despite having literally no evidence + there being several viable scenarios where she is, is not exactly filling me with the utmost confidence here