Read up.
I am the Wicked. I become evil if the Clockhand is on me. This does not activate if I am dead. Therefore, kill me.
Chieftain and Effigy add Outsiders (1 each), so Light is claiming that we have at least one of those in play.
My play makes no sense if I’m fakeclaiming. I don’t think there’s a single evil role that benefits from dying, although I admit I didn’t read thoroughly.
Any good script has a way to stop the Outsider count from being definite (and therefore exploitable to confirm some players as good).
I mean, technically the Effigy’s ability is just offing themselves anyhow? But they’re probably better served doing that at night to try and throw off killcounts.
Either way, it doesn’t make sense for me to do this as the Effigy, because that adds an outsider, and if another player claimed outsider and no Chieftain stepped up, I would be outed.
I would like to ask this.
Since Light outed, does this mean we are always voting Light no matter what?
Or are there circumstances when we risk leaving Light alive?
Technically, we could tack onto that “if we have compelling reason to believe that the clockhand is not near Light”, but if we have that sort of info, we already have the game damn near locked. The only character that gets info on the clockhand N1 is the Diviner, who should have learned a player who isn’t the Clockhand last night (and therefore not the Demon, because the Clockhand always starts on Demon). Light could turn as soon as tonight if Silviu is Demon, and without a solid way to prove whether or not Light is likely to turn, we have to off him here, particularly when our voting power is already 7-3 as it is. Letting Light’s vote flip evil would be horrific.
1 Like
The only reason I would argue maybe we would follow the Stalker more, is every night they know if the closest living player (below the list) to them is a minion.
So, getting rid of 1 would leave them to find the next person to them.
(Then again, I am fully new so shrug idk whether the risk is worth it or what)