You mean if the clockhand is evil?
Soothsayer is malfunctioning if the clockhand is evil or themselves. Since it started on the Demon, we can pull out one possible clockhand who would definitely be evil, so we have nine options for where the clockhand is and three of them cause Cloned to malfunction (the two Minions and Cloned himself).
You keep forgetting about how the info can be bad, which is weird considering how much bad info is supposedly part of your life right now.
What the hell are both of you saying…
GGhana is going back and fourth or some crap and I don’t get any of this…
If we had a Stargazer, they’d be learning the clockhand’s alignment, but part of me thinks that hosts wouldn’t put that in at the same time as Soothsayer because those two abilities combo together in a kinda busted way.
Like you’re just sitting back and saying why my theories don’t work but I really need other people to be giving worlds right now
Ok so first of all. Is there a Cheiftain? If there is, I believe now is a crucial time to out themselves
I think the world we’re looking at is that you’re just a Minion. To be perfectly frank, I’ve been entertaining your worldcrafting to see if it slips any information. You seem to be very sure there’s a Viceroy, for example.
Well I’m not, but at this point town needs to share theories. I’m not gonna let my ego get bruised because other people think I’m a minion
Honest question, in a world where I’m a minion. Why would I go balls in and try to get Intensify and Whysper killed? I even said myself that I’d be confirmed a minion.
Alright so let me think about this…
So what we have so far is…
Light is Wicked
Cloned is Soothsayer who learned that Whysper is the Demon
PKR is Ambusher who found GGhana as a Demon
GGhana is bloodletter who confirms Cloned as Good and not bloodied
Well, I tinfoiled earlier that you’re the Eclipse yourself, who knew you were poisoning Cloned, saw him claim Soothsayer with a Demon ping, and immediately jumped onto that info, floating a Bloodletter claim to vouch for Cloned and make his info look good while simultaneously “missing” ways that it could be poisoned (which you’ve done twice now; Eclipse and the Soothsayer ability itself).
But technically, you don’t even have to be the Eclipse; you could be the other Minion who knows that the Soothsayer info is bad because you know who the Demon is and that it’s not Whysper like Cloned is claiming, so you’re jumping in to try and push the theory leading town down the garden path. If you get Intensify and Whysper both killed, then town only has one more execution and they’ve wasted so much time that they’d basically just have to take a potshot at Demon.