[Misc] Blood on the Forums V: Ides of Blood - Good Wins!

[GGhana]

Oh you mean me saying “I don’t want to clear her because she has info that makes her look good?” That was just mech because her claim seems legit.

[Tangeld]

1 and 2 both seem like wowee plays from Ghana, so I’m placing enough faith in his ability as a player to rule them out. And that actually works against 4 as well. Someone give me a reason why 3 is not viable, or I think I’m left to conclude that it’s the most likely.

[GGhana]

@Tangeld

If both are town: Ghana’s the Diviner, Whysper’s the Bloodletter, PKR and Cloned both have bad info, and Ghana, as town, is pushing for the execution of someone that he’s basically clearing as town, not to mention someone who gets good info for relatively little cost if it’s really a Retro game (bloodying people would arguably be a net negative if we had Wendigo, but if both are good, the apparent consensus is not Wendigo game).

I literally thought I had the game solved Tan. That’s why I wanted to kill her even though I townread her. How did you miss that?

[Intensify]

@GGhana

That was just mech because her claim seems legit.

Wdym “legit”. Go into more detail?

Also I want answers about your read on Whysper as well…

[Intensify]

@GGhana

anyways

Nerd reads

whysper town
Tan town

Light scum
Pkr scum

sheep reads thanks

Also when I’m talking about your read on Whysper, I’m talking about this specific post. I’m not sure how all of Whysper’s posts before all of that felt towny to you, I need you to clarify

[Tangeld]

@Amelia @EliThePsycho Who has been nominated so far today, and by whom?

[GGhana]

Basically unless she’s trying to pocket me. I don’t see how she’s scum. She had a role ready that checks out. Her night actions make logical sense. And her posts lack any sort of agenda she’s trying to push.

[EliThePsycho]

GGhana has nominated Intensify, and Intensify has nominated Whysper

[GGhana]

@Whysper

Actually since you are around, I wanted to ask about my role. I’m not sure how to use it effectively. But I assume I shouldn’t openly claim, so maybe I can whisper with you about it.

It was right at the start of day 1. So a micro town read was good enough for me.

[GGhana]

And even now. I think this post is still really Townie.

[Intensify]

@GGhana

whysper town

I was talking about this read.

@GGhana

Her night actions make logical sense.

??? explain? What was her night action?

@GGhana

And her posts lack any sort of agenda she’s trying to push.

Can’t this just be explained by: Light was gonna die 100% of the time day 1, therefore no point in having a push on someone else

[GGhana]

@Intensify

??? explain? What was her night action?

this seems like the most obvious trap to get a secondhand kill in the world

[Intensify]

Oh yeah wait a second… Tan you got Whysper’s role? Did she claim Bloodletter?

[Intensify]

Fair enough. But you should still explain how her night action made sense.

[GGhana]

@Intensify

I was talking about this read.

Yes and? I explained it.

[GGhana]

I can’t go into much detail. But she basically explained in a lot of detail who she picked and why. And the other people she might’ve picked.

[GGhana]

honestly

can someone nominate me

I think at this point I’ve served my purpose. And I’ve already claimed so I’m fine with being executed

[Tangeld]

She asked if Bloodletter was worth using, since it bloodies someone every time. I didn’t know if that was a full claim or just a really bad attempt at a soft, but I still treated Ghana claiming it like a doubleclaim, and given that PKR was saying Ghana was a Minion, I was trying not to out that I knew of another possible Bloodletter claim because that just puts a target on Whysper.

[Intensify]

I don’t see what that would accomplish

[Tangeld]

Also, I may have given a really bad attempt at a soft right back to Whysper, and considering that I’m not dead, that makes me also want to trust her.)