[Misc] Blood on the Forums V: Ides of Blood - Good Wins!

Forum Matches Completed
#1043

@Tangeld

when PKR claimed to you D1, did he tell you that he’d seen Ghana as a Minion? If so, how did that influence your perspective on D1?

#1044
  1. Tangeld - claims Ambusher, says Secondhand is in play + Gorta is Minion (died N3)
  2. Silviu - Stargazer, N2 Good N3 Good
  3. Light - claims outsider, executed D1
  4. an_gorta_pratai
  5. Magnus - claims Chieftan, presumably doesn’t conflict with Light
  6. Whysper - bloodletter claim - not sure if she’s claimed her info?
  7. clonedcheese - died N3
  8. Intensify
  9. PokemonKidRyan - died N2 - Stalker, GGhana is minion
  10. GGhana - claims Diviner, cloned not the Demon, Demon is Retro
#1045
  1. Tangeld - claims Ambusher, says Secondhand is in play + Gorta is Minion (died N3)
  2. Silviu - Stargazer, N2 Good N3 Good
  3. Light - claims Wicked, executed D1
  4. an_gorta_pratai
  5. Magnus - claims Chieftan, presumably doesn’t conflict with Light
  6. Whysper - bloodletter claim - not sure if she’s claimed her info?
  7. clonedcheese - died N3
  8. Intensify
  9. PokemonKidRyan - died N2 - pretty sure he’s claimed but I forget what?
  10. GGhana - claims Diviner, cloned not the Demon, Demon is Retro

edited Light’s entry to be slightly more accurate

#1046

Gorta Eclipse/Ghana Secondhand/Whysper Retro makes perfect sense mechanically but zero sense socially

#1047

like GGhana was saying Whysper was town but he was also trying to get her executed

#1048

wow I’ve been in this game for half an hour and I already have more posts than Gorta

:joy_tree:

2 Likes
#1049

I meant that Wicked would genuinely claim early if they intended to win as good, since winning as good is far easier than the inverse, and as such Light’s actions made sense. Ghana proposed killing Silviu since she could be Demon if Light was Minion, which didn’t make sense with the idea that Light is innocent.

Light claimed Wicked, and I knew there was a Wicked in game, so he was likely to be sharing the truth, unless the real Wicked had stayed silent for some reason, so he wasn’t ‘locktown’, but likely to be innocent.

1 Like
#1050

I did in fact know that Ghana was seen as Minion, and I was concerned at the time that Ghana could be Viceroy poisoning me, but with the way the claims and info have shaken out, I don’t think Ghana can be Viceroy anymore. Hell, he actually had a workable theory at one point, but it had your slot being evil, and that’s seeming much less likely than it was when Silviu had the slot.

1 Like
#1051

hm

I was briefly tinfoiling that Tan was minion who offed herself for towncred but I don’t think she would choose to specifically call out Gorta as a minion in that case

like if her goal is to discredit a villager she could choose a villager who’s actually doing literally anything whatsoever

#1052

Magnus’s response checks out, I think he’s probably telling the truth here

1 Like
#1053

Yay.
Am I towncore now?

#1054

not sure yet

#1055

has cloned claimed

he died overnight so as ‘people who should claim’ go he’s high on the list

#1056

I don’t know.
He implied he had a role with active actions and feedback, though.

#1057

Cloned was Soothsayer claim, got Whysper as Retro N2, but it seemed like he forgot that earlier and started asking who had a redcheck on Whysper.

1 Like
#1058

think it’s very unlikely we have both of these

and fairly unlikely we have this
or

this?

so we should be safe to execute today? 6p -> execute brings us to 5p -> 2ish people die overnight

#1059

no wait that doesn’t work because we could end up with all 3 living players being evil

#1060
  1. Tangeld - claims Ambusher, says Secondhand is in play + Gorta is Minion (died N3)
  2. Silviu - Stargazer, N2 Good N3 Good
  3. Light - claims Wicked, executed D1
  4. an_gorta_pratai
  5. Magnus - claims Chieftan, presumably doesn’t conflict with Light
  6. Whysper - bloodletter claim - not sure if she’s claimed her info?
  7. clonedcheese - died N3 - Whysper is Retro
  8. Intensify
  9. PokemonKidRyan - died N2 - pretty sure he’s claimed but I forget what?
  10. GGhana - claims Diviner, cloned not the Demon, Demon is Retro

edited Light’s entry to be slightly more accurate

#1061

Ghosts have votes, so as long as one town member lives we should be fine, right?

#1062

Assuming we correctly execute the Demon.

1 Like