[Misc] Blood on the Forums V: Ides of Blood - Good Wins!

Forum Matches Completed
#1123

I think the most likely option here is that Gorta is town and Tan is poisoned by Viceroy!Ghana? not sure

#1124

It’s also worth noting that I told Ghana that I was going to tell cloned to check Whysper again tonight

#1125

I was playing some 4d chess because I was bored
Once again, I’m still set on Whysper.

#1126

Wait, hold up.

#1127
  1. Tangeld - can’t be demon (dead)
  2. Arete - me
  3. Light - can’t be demon (dead)
  4. an_gorta_pratai - unlikely to be Demon (Tan got a minion check on him, very unlikely that a malfunctioning Good role would get a minion check on a Demon, unlikely Tan would fake a minion check on the Demon as evil, if she’s working properly then he’s not the Demon)
  5. Magnus - socially claim makes sense, also we know there’s some role that modifies the number of outsiders
  6. Whysper
  7. clonedcheese - can’t be the Demon (dead)
  8. Intensify - socially very unlikely to be the Demon because they tried to get themself executed at EoD2
  9. PokemonKidRyan - can’t be the Demon (dead)
  10. GGhana - unlikely to be the Demon for basically the same reason as Gorta
#1128

basically what I’m saying is that I think it’s really unlikely the Demon is anyone but Whysper

#1129

does anyone want to dispute any of my clears

#1130

also @evil this means that if Whysper is the Demon you basically have to try to convince people that the Demon is exactly me

glgl :slightly_smiling_face:

#1131

Clears have happened in similar ways many times in the past.

#1132

Other than that, I have no complaints.

#1133

Voting himself hands up while I was in thread getting him close enough for me to slam him is not something a demon does.

#1134

Especially after I had stated intent to vote.

#1135

Didn’t I do it first botf?

#1136

Gorta has to be one of three roles (one of which is town and two of which are scum)

I think it’s really unlikely for him to be the Eclipse (one of the scum roles)

although he could in theory be the Viceroy

#1137

Do I look like I was in the first BotF?

#1138

the one issue I have with this solve is that I’m not sure who the second minion (taking GGhana as close to lock minion)

#1139

The only way Intensify being Demon lines up with him selfvoting at EoD2 is if he thought no one else would vote. Light being on makes this super unlikely, unless Intensify made some super gambit that selfvoting would make him look townie enough in that moment that Light wouldn’t want to spend ghost vote to hammer, and I don’t mean this to be mean, but I don’t think Intensify’s bold enough to make a move like that.

1 Like
#1140

Confirms -

gorta <-> Tangled

Whysper -> Silviu

Magnus -> Light

PKR x-> GGhana

Cloned x-> Whysper

N2 Clock - Not on an outsider - Secondhand in play potentially

——

Tangeld - Claims Ambusher - Secondhand is a minion in play

  • Arete - Claims Stargazer - N2 - Clockhand on Good

Light - Wicked

an_gorta_pratai - Claims Blasphemer- “There is an Ambusher in play”

Magnus - Claims Chieftain/Effigy - N2 - Clockhand not on Outsider

  • Whysper - Claims Bloodletter - N2 - Silviu Good - Wants to claim swap with Ghana

Clonedcheese - Claims Soothsayer - N2 - Whysper Retrogradus

Intensify - Claims (Crusader?) Warrior

PokemonKidRyan - Claims Stalker, Claimed N1 Positive on GGhana

  • GGhana - Claims Diviner - Retrogradus, clonedcheese is not the demon

  • means a copcheck

#1141

That’s everything I had yesterday

#1142

Actually, wait, hold on… Unless I’m mistaken, this solve requires everyone but Whysper and Ghana to be good.
Me because Gorta saw Ambusher
You because your info clears down the PoE
Light because Outsider
Gorta because my poisoned info and your info
Magnus because your info and Cloned’s info
Cloned because redcheck on Demon and then dying
Intensify because lolselfvote
PKR because redcheck on Ghana
…Am I missing something? Logically, something has to be wrong here.