[Misc] Blood on the Forums V: Ides of Blood - Good Wins!

Forum Matches Completed
#1704

Do we have any evidence of that?

#1705

I think there’s a flaw in your plan you haven’t noticed?

#1706

Yeah… because your argument to save Whysper is only dependant on Whysper not being scum…

#1707

Because it’s possible for her to be the secondhand?

Like again, let’s just yeet them both instead of sacrificing the potential win

#1708

then we kill her, there’s only one nightkill, and we go into tomorrow with 4p alive and have another chance to hit the Demon

#1709

oh wait I misread your post

#1710

Arete is gamer and also right

#1711

Basically, if we miss the yeet and evil kills you then we might kill the wrong one

#1712

Listen, what if either Tan or Cloned was Effigy, offing themselves, trying to get us to panic and think there’s a Secondhand, and the Retrogradus is Intensify?

#1713

Actually, hold on. What if the demon is Arete, hypothetically? Is that mechanically possible in any world?

#1714

give me a mechanically possible list of three evil players and their roles, in which Whysper is good

#1715

Wait but… wouldn’t that mean another outsider then if you’re Chieftain?

#1716

I have to go eat dinner, I’ll be back later

#1717

Effigy is minion.

#1718

yeah but there has to be another outsider

#1719

I am aware of that yes. But I’m saying there would be 2 outsiders then right?

#1720

Uh, no? Am I missing something?

#1721

no Intensify is saying that Effigy adds an Outsider, so there would be two Outsiders rather than just one

ok I’m really going to eat dinner now, in the meantime come up with

#1722

effigy adds an outsider

#1723

Where?