Morphogenetic Mafia - Thread A

[Trochilidae]

the purpose of the question was to know whose read it was as katze scumreading chloe and sulit scumreading marl are two entirely different things to consider

[KyoDaz]

And what would you gain from knowing that answer

[Trochilidae]

i literally said i’d considered the mindset from a town and scum perspective and decided it made more sense from town!min

[min]

can you like

stop purposely removing everything I’ve said up to now because I know you’re doing it

because I’ve never said not to yeet eli i explained several times that I am worried and we should be cautious

The more you only use one post I said out of context the more I’m going to believe you genuinely are a wolf btw as your reasoning on me is absolute crap and you clearly haven’t read like half of my posts

[KyoDaz]

And I don’t get how you’ve managed to reach that conclusion even after your post.

[KyoDaz]

Quote any post you’ve made where you defend Eli not off the basis that he’s wolfy as a villager

[Trochilidae]

knowing if it was sulit’s original read or kat’s original read is something to gain in and of itself?
part of the way i like to read people is separating their content into original thoughts and thoughts from others they support/object to and considering the two motivations for each

i don’t understand why you’re asking this

[Trochilidae]

what exactly don’t you get? i’d be happy to explain if you go into more detail about what you don’t understand

[KyoDaz]

Right okay and what do you think of sulit’s slot now that you know they aren’t sheeping katze but formed that read on their own?

[min]

@min

don’t want us to vote eli today. I have reasons but primarily we will figure out his alignment over more than one day

Because he’s basically almost been a wagoned and mled In like every game he’s been in

So

@min

Eli is a wagon in like every game he plays

we are clearly reading him wrong and we need to actually figure out how to read him

@min

I’m not saying “never vote eli ever”

I’m saying “think before voting him”

@min

I never said don’t kill eli ever, as I said before

@min

He’s acting the same as he has in like

every other game I’ve had with him as town so far

it’s not a confident read (not as much as the others) but I still think he’s gth town

@min

I explained why and also said it wasn’t the most serious read

@min

my guts just telling me things

@min

if you don’t like that that’s fine

I can see why you don’t

@min

Yeah, I’ll concede as my read isn’t as deep as people think it is

@min

Ghana definetely doesn’t like my read on eli

I’ll probably wait for him to post more before reading him regardless of how I feel, sorry

@min

I’m just worried because both eli and ybw are 100% ml bait as town

it’s why I’m so nervous to ever wagon them. like eli was literally the ic

@min

Because the two of them have one thing in common which is they unintentionally are scummy. They are inactive, they fluff a lot when they are active, and ybw is so not confident in his own reads

@min

you guys are thinking I’m saying like

“oh don’t ever kill them”

I’m not

I’m just worried

I’m not going to contest against both of their deaths immensely because of my worrying

Wow look

None of these say “don’t kill eli ever”

find someone else’s posts to take out of context

[KyoDaz]

@Trochilidae

what exactly don’t you get? i’d be happy to explain if you go into more detail about what you don’t understand

@KyoDaz

There are 14 other people here with one thread completely out of our control that also have some sway on our lynch bc we want to kill the same people as we do here
Maybe if min was in towncore and / or actually defending them with concrete reasoning I could see where you’re coming from because it could reasonably be a deciding factor of whether or not Eli lives
min defending Eli with incredibly poor reasoning that won’t sway anybody is definitely not going to be a deciding factor in whether or not town!Eli lives; which is why I don’t think that defending Eli here at all is town AI and you’ve completely missed this out

Do you see any fault in this

[Trochilidae]

i would’ve considered that a point in sulit’s favor were it her thought
as it is though, it was NAI and frankly didn’t affect my read on them at all

[KyoDaz]

These all detail that Eli is wolfy as a villager

Concede, your reasoning is poor

[KyoDaz]

I 100% understand that you say we should give Eli more time bc you believe he doesn’t get enough as town to look towny
But why is that convincing and the only reason you have for not lynching Eli d1 as the wolfiest player in the game is meta

[min]

these all also aren’t hard defending eli like you’re falsely claiming they are I’m not like anyone else this game I’m not letting you take my shit out of context and get me mled

[min]

I never said dont yeet eli

why are people saying I am

[KyoDaz]

It doesn’t matter that they’re not hard defending Eli, it’s not justifiably a reason to not kill someone if they’re wolfy

[min]

I never said don’t kill them I said think more before doing so

[Trochilidae]

yes actually
because i’m trying to read min as town min or wolf min which are different than the universal town-wolf standard
and frankly, i think you’re overestimating min’s presence in general (sorry min) and confusing a “loud” voice with an “impactful” one
min isn’t a 5-star or an alice, their word isn’t law and won’t be taken in as high of a regard as you’re insinuating

[KyoDaz]

@min

I don’t want us to vote eli today. I have reasons but primarily we will figure out his alignment over more than one day

You did say this but then you changed your read and I’ll concede that you did change it
However it doesn’t change the fact that your basis for these reads is that Eli is wolfy as a villager, and what I am arguing is that is not convincing enough for Trochi to think you wouldn’t say that as a wolf