This is nice, watching GGhana spam the thread. Now I see why heâs top poster and barely interacted with him at all.
@Ephemeral Chili has disappeared, anything new going on in Thread A?
I think you owned yourself here.
Since you tried to refute my argument about it why have you suddenly given up? That makes no sense.
again not my fault you say bullshit and I call you out on it
also no because Iâm on mobile
anyway Iâm gonna ignore GGhana because he doesnât even know how to make a point against me.
@Chloe youâre currently voting me and can probably actually make a good case, can you state the reasons youâre scumreading me (or link me to the post if I missed it)
Because you make a point and then suddenly change your mind on it when I contradict it like âthat wasnât the pointâ
You know what, Iâll give you one last chance. Structure your points in bullet points or something with the reasons you scumread me. Perfectly easy to read and practically impossible to have âmiscommunication.â
But knowing you, you wonât do that because when I point something out thatâs the best excuse you got.
You see your problem is that you think Iâm an idiot, and you hope if you say that enough Iâll go away. But that doesnât work on me.
I want to know your thought process and if it comes from town or scum. So explain.
This is false because Iâve never contradicted it.
Why do you think Iâm lying instead of you making a mistake?
wOW tHIs Is FalSE, I nEVeR sAId ThiS.
See what I mean? I said I contradict one of your points and then youâre like âthatâs not my pointâ.
from what i hear, seems dead
same as usual
1 Like
Because you are an idiot and we both know it at this point, you literally CTRL + Vâd your argument you had against me onto Ephemeral moments after I spoke to you. You never stated any reads or reasoning when you started your push with a vote on me or anything so when I called you out on it, you pulled up some bullshit, spewed it then got contradicted.
Go on then, what were those points you were intending if I âsomehow misreadâ them.
Read on marshal day 1 felt forced. It felt like you knew marshal would be a threat but then later on you couldnât find a way to stop scumreading him and look legit, this is why you kinda casually accepted marshal being town (and you made a few posts about him being scum at start of day 1 about him looking bad to not look too fake)
You were coasting because people townread you for your talk about your chat with Trochi. When people stopped doing that you made a push on YBW, but since it makes no logical sense and itâs unfalsifiable I donât see how a Townie wouldnât notice how their push on a person makes no sense.
Pretend this is like, an officially formatted mod message
Itâs just a game, no personal attacks, etc etc. If youâre getting heated, take a break.
also since I had a nice raid in tarkov Iâm in a good mood
so let me tell you two smth (gghana/wazza)
at this point your argument feels drained out, youâre going in circles âno uâ x infinity
take a break, focus on other things
talk about other reads/feels, maybe drop a case
but stop engaging each other if all youâre going to do is go in circles, itâs flooding the thread and not accomplishing anything else afaict
my 2c
Where did this point come from? This wasnât in your original post. Better yet, if I was Mafia and I was forcing a read on Marshal, why wouldnât I just Townread him? After all he was talking about that he townread me and thatâs why I scumread him as I saw it as pocketing (and then some other points later on but those are irrelevant unless you want me to post them).
Marshal was townreading me. This makes no sense.
Because it made perfect sense to me that he was scum and then his EOD made that so much worse and clearly so many people agreed to me since everyone in Thread fucking A were talking about how it was bad.
Did you just ignore the point where I stated what Mistâs answer to your question was? Mafia Factional Kill is Mandatory and cannot self-target.
what, my push on Marshal was from the Start of D1 and then at the End, I barely showed up in the middle, what points are you looking at that I had against Marshal that werenât at the start?
I was coasting because I did a little thing called hosting a Misc which are very stressful to get started. And if you talk about the day previously, I did stuff that day as well and I even found time to talk at the end and stay awake till 4am for the EoD.
No one really stopped Townreading me until I spoke with my push on YBW. Not that I saw anyway.
yeah youâre right, since it does make sense. Itâs called Night Kill Analysis, you should try it.
Easier said than done because if I start ignoring him, knowing him heâs just going to make the point of âYouâre ignoring me because you know Iâm right.â
No it doesnât. Firstly again impossible to prove (we canât know that YBW is the sort of person who would let their other scum decide all the kills) and just from an analytic perspective makes no sense at all (why would scum kill their primary defender of a LHF slot? For Vbucks?)
Considering how people said you were coasting right at the start of the day Iâm not gonna dignify this with a response.
Ah Iâm sorry, this is my fault. I meant today (Iâm on phone so I typed the wrong number)
Eh I kinda get where youâre coming from. I do think that you still handled marshal in a bad way but Iâll drop this point.
Not sure how this refutes my point, I donât like how you handled him because I feel like you did it in a passive âtrying not to rock the boat but rock it at the same timeâ way
Marshal is a skilled player, I think at the SoD1 trying to make him look bad is wise no matter what alignment you are (scum because heâs a good player, town because heâs annoying)
Any sort of âWHY WOULD I DO X AS SCUMâ when X makes perfect sense to do as scum is not gonna convince me
(Also for the first point, I donât think I made that part of my read clear enough looking back. Sorry bout that.)
