i got the same feeling as I got from Arete in JoJo Part 7
which is “I’m too much of a newbie to read them today, but when i read over most of their posts really quickly I get a sinking feeling in my gut”
that’s… not exactly helpful tbh
but alright, noted
I’m not clearing kat, and don’t think they should be clear. I think every thing kat has done is uber-comfortably inside of their wolf range.
If you have evidence that kat’s doing really villagery things, I’ll listen, when kat is v other people get there before me. But kat’s a really good wolf sooo I dont think they deserve anything past a light villa read.
To boil it down:
GGhana is my personal pick.
Ephemeral feels like a paranoia pick more than anything, honestly.
YBW and TL might contain a wolf. I won’t townshield them. I just don’t have a lot of faith.
Hard vetoing kat, chloe, wazza, marshal kills for today. I think the first two have been towny and the last two have been towny enough.
I’ll re-evaluate if needed.
I care about the “whys” and the analysis.
Anyone can pump out a reads list
explaining it with trackable reasoning is a lot harder
To break it down into categories you probably like more:
Wolf: GGhana
Maybe wolves?? (poe wolves??): YBW, TL
Paranoia: Ephemeral
Townleaning: Wazza, Marshal
Town: Kat, Chloe
All I’ve done this entire game was give you every bit of reasoning I actually believe. You can trust me on that or not, but I feel comfortable saying it.
well its just far far less than I’ve seen or come to expect
So my read isn’t changing
maybe kat has something that we didn’t see
My greatest priority is to get a second wolfread, but I’m not sure if I’ll manage before EoD.
Part of my read on kat is frankly their focus on the chloe slot
As I understand it, both kat and their partner have this brain meld thing going with chloe
On that note I’d naturally expect them to focus most of their attention/body of work on each other at least throughout the initial stages of the game. What I’m trying to get at is that the dynamics surrounding the slots and kats approach to chloe/the game thus far tracks with how i’d expect them to do it as a villager within the circumstances. Obligatory caveat being that I’m not familiar enough with them to confidently claim this is how they’d think, but it feels like the most reasonable conclusion to me rn
On an intuitive level I haven’t gotten any notable pings from the slot so far which I also consider a plus but ymmv
Yeah that makes sense on how you got there at least. sulit and kat are both chloe simps and kat/chloe notably have some sort of soulread on each other.
I wouldn’t clear off of it, it isn’t outside of kat’s wolfrange or ?really? pushing it. It’s annoying to me because it feels like kat’s analyses have been lacking outside of that but I can’t say this isn’t how kat would play it as villager.
Alright, noted
This makes the issue harder for me though because aside from kat, I don’t have anyone atm who I feel like I can clear confidently in good conscience
Even slots which I’ve noted to have any number of villagery contributions/interactions as a whole have had me pause instinctively at points for certain reasons(most notably in this category being you/chloe)
and then the others are various shades of “how do I get there on this without being monke”
maybe instead of focusing too hard on having super hard clears I can settle for just “various shades of villagery” and kill whoever doesn’t meet the criteria
i just feel like that’s keeping the bar a bit low and it’s meh
but alas
marshal’s drunk
1 Like
oh man I was jammin’ to ace attorney ost’s and then godot’s theme starts playing
fuck yeah🤠