Hmm
I’m not seeing how all of this makes him scum other than the fact that most of his conclusions were very weak and that he refused to re-evaluate despite 4/5 of them being pretty much guaranteed town
^^^
This is a scummy stubbornness because he doesn’t have a strong case for any of them being scum unlike VCFM
https://forum.imperium42.com/t/nier-drakengard-forum-mafia-night-i-pascals-despair-26-29/76065/2692?u=boss110
Only this post he mention you, other than that Math has gone fully aggressive on Magnus
I’m partial to getting Fire out of these, considering the continued ‘I don’t know what’s going on’ from them.
Scum that doesn’t know how to get a hook in thread?
Probably not.
His team would coach him to have more of a splash in thread.
Math’s conclusion on me being scum puppet is completely unfounded and more reason to sus him because the rest of the “associations” are likely Town
They are very pushable but their wagon hasn’t picked up as much steam as I’d expect if they were town
Edit: town would be more pushable, and Math has importantly listed a lot of ‘potential scum’ who are probably town
Ninja’s an interesting case.
The fact they were poisoned probably makes Zone the poisoner.
Ninja also has some very agreeable reads, but they are very similar to the consensus minus Isaac.
Me and Geyde conversation about Math (G = Geyde and B = Boss110)
“There has to be at least one scum in Meto wagon, knowing this, who do you think is scum?” - G
“Math, obviously” - B
“But who would be with Math there? Math is keeping presumably his scum partner Magnus alive for what reason? He could bussed him for towncred” - G
“Magnus is unlikely to survive and Math would look scummy for it considering he CFD off his scumread onto town” - G
“Magnus has a one-time use night ability that’s probably have something to do with kill, either that or he has an ability that can fake results which he can possibly use to confirm himself and buy another day” - B
“Math could also just ITA Magnus tomorrow and still get the towncred” - B
“Can you extrapolate any other scum on the wagon based on their interactions with Math?” - G
“Mercenary, she barely interacts with Math besides this post (Post 1495) where she just simply say “I like this post”, you can ISO Merc and the only time she talks with Math it’s either fluff post or talking about omnimiller” - B
“And why do you think that is the case? Why would scum not want to at least try to interact with each other?” - G
“Merc interacts with Math but pretty much all of them are fluff post. She hasn’t disagreed with Math read once nor agreeing with it” - B
"They clearly agreed with the read on me at the time I was scumreading them - G
"For thought, what were Math reactions to the dayvig on me vs the one on Sweety? Was he more on the dot with the latter than the former? Why do you think they wouldn’t comment on their top scumread being shot? - G
“I can’t find Math reaction on Sweety flips, really suspicious IMO” - B
“That’s not really suspicious” - G
“Other than that Math only posts that talk about you after you died is only the facts that he didn’t know you were dayvig” - B
“Did he re-evaluate his read at all? Or, did he just continue despite his top scum fliping town” - G
“Marg had a change of perspective after my flip, so Math (who also thought I was scum, and made a huge case of it) should logically have reconsidered” - G
“I’m not seeing how all of this makes him scum other than the fact that most of his conclusions were very weak and that he refused to re-evaluate despite 4/5 of them being pretty much guaranteed town” - G
“This is a scummy stubbornness because he doesn’t have a strong case for any of them being scum unlike VCFM” - G
“After that early push on me Math hasn’t talked about me ever since” - B
“And Icibalus picked up the torch in scumreading you, but he dropped it” - G
“Math conclusion on me being scum puppet is completely unfounded and more reason to sus him because the rest of the “associations” are likely Town” - G
“A lot of what they are doing is looking fishy” - G
“They are very pushable but their wagon hasn’t picked up as much steam as I’d expect if they were town, town would be more pushable, and Math has importantly listed a lot of ‘potential scum’ who are probably town” - G
I will ask alice if I can put this in my log
