The potential for an extra kill is worth more than the guarente of an existing one.
Why does Brewer only have two uses? And thatās the only ability? I mean, thatās a converted Alchemist, who usually jumps on the opportunity to side with Undead/Cult already.
Heās going to need to be stronger.
But Forsaken looks amazing, although Scorned should probably only be converted if they havenāt already won.
As for the Joker/Jester, I donāt think he should be punished for being lynched. But bringing back Deceive to work like Forsakenās frame would be nice. (Although Framer in ToS is incredibly underrated)
Brewer has 2 uses since it kills. It does have 3 chances to be healed, but it doesnāt notify the target. Iām not sure if it is as or more powerful than Revenge.
Scorned definitely shouldnāt be converted if they have one.
Iām not really sure what to do with Joker.
Iām not really sure what to do with Joker.
Like I said, just make them exactly like Fool, but:
-
No penalty for lynching them.
-
Their ability to frame themselves is replaced with an ability to make themselves look innocent.
Thatās it. They keep trollbox and hide, and they now win with Unseen like any other Unseen role. This makes for a fairly powerful Unseen role, but at the cost of converting someone who was not really an enemy in the first place.
2 Likes
Nightshade poisoning has nothing to do with the argument lol ā¦ assassin can poison whether thereās an enforcer or sellsword
Brewer has hidden Nightshade poisoning. I think thatās much more powerful than an assassin poisoning.
I still hate ābrewerā as a name. It absolutely sounds like a version of the Drunk - itās an actual word that refers to people who brew alchohol specifically, so applying it to a converted Alchemist makes no sense.
I changed the Jokerās abilities.
@Aquillion I donāt have a better name for Brewer, and what the hell even is a thaumaturge?