also wait
if we know that appel was OE’d by yellow can’t we have min exhume appel as a quasi-cop check on yellow
does it work like that
Thats what I thought when it was mentioned earlier XD
I asked earlier, whats a thunderdome?
ATNoName (strigoi)
Eli
Marluxion
Windwardaway
Yellow
Pokemonkidryan
Oogway
Napoleon
Blulance
Min
silviu
katze
And what the heck, so few messages, I expected to have to read like 500+ on my break.
I would’ve said a joke here, but I thought that finding out the culprit starts with N2 although I did it on N1
It’s when two players have contradicting mechanical claims, which means at least one of them is garunteed mafia.
Sometimes people can thunderdome each other just off of social reads but it’s rare
1 Like
Is that town to scum or?
The top are people I have varying degrees of townleans on
The bottom are people I do not.
(ATNoName is at the top because while I do not townlean him I believe his claim)
Ahh ok, I mean, I agree with some of it, although I believe Min is town and I don’t believe Eli is, but I dont have anything on Eli that screams bad XD Same goes with Pokemon.
yeah but conversion was N1, not N2 (or at least I suspect it was).
that’s a personal opinion. My personal opinion is maybe/maybe/maybe/maybe/idk/idk/idk lol. Never played with wolf!Katze, Marshal or Eli before. The other three I’ve caught before as wolves. I don’t know how easy it is for everyone else to catch wolf!me, but I’m pretty sure Kat and Marl can catch me as scum, and probably Marshal as well.
This is how Zone screwed up his fakeclaim in EFoL 4 lmao, he fakeclaimed paladin without knowing how it worked.
uh what
yes, the game thread opens on D1 so the first night is N1 (when there was no kill). The order goes: D1, N1, D2, N2, D3…
I’m kind of confused but you mean to say, after D1 (the 24 h day with no voting), you checked Napoleon?
No I didn’t lol, I was trying to hint that you should read the cult class cards, but then I fucked up and read them wrong anyway lol.
Yeah well, someone’s bound to have fakeclaimed by now. Either a prince or a cultist lol.
Thinking that despite townreading someone, they could still be a wolf somehow.
in that case doesn’t it make more sense to have min exhume Grey instead?
calling for people to vote within the thunderdomed candidates, meaning that the assumption is at least one of them is a wolf. If Marl says that Marshal and Napoleon should thunderdome, it means that he is suggesting the rest of us should figure out which of those two is a wolf. Sort of like an unofficial way of gladiating, I guess.
2 Likes
I mean, if people think they screwed up then wouldnt Silviu be the biggest target right now? I mean Day 1 has always been day 1 right? in ToL and ToS and it also said Day 1 at the top.
Wind’s reads (unordered, can’t be arsed to put them in order):
ATN - don’t really care; I’ll buy the claim of some sort of neut and won’t vote him out
Eli - slight townlean but could change later
Marl - townlean, not interested in voting him out right now
Yellow - townlean, think they were starting town anyway but idk if they would’ve been an N1 convert target.
PKR - townread, and he wouldn’t have claimed to prevent Marl from getting converted if he’s scum imo
Oogway - kinda nulltown, I think he’s a bit of an LHF here for not being very active and also claiming during Kat’s RT
Napoleon - null…town? idk, I think it’s possible he’s a wolf but not with Marshal, or at least they aren’t both starting cultists.
BlueLance - nulltown, don’t really feel like explaining this
Min - townread, also don’t feel like explaining this
Silviu - nulltown, his paladin claim kind of set my alarms off but I don’t think he scumslipped tbh
Katze - scumlean, I think she was trying to bait the BD stronger roles to claim, and then backtracked to act like she’s against mass claiming (probably because she’ll get boxed in if we do)
Marshal - scumlean, very possibly the N1 convert but could still be one of the starting cult members; either way she’d likely be the ritualist. She’s not cult with Napoleon.
the more concerning thing is that it also literally says which Night it is during the Night phases, and Silviu legit could’ve missed that as either alignment. I do believe he screwed up counting the night phases, thinking it went N1, D1, N2, D2, etc. but it basically means nothing about his claim in that case.
also, yeah, I already know I have too many townleans and I don’t really care at the moment
Let’s make this clear, I think you’re scum because you’re looking for easy mislynches. You have been so focused on my slot that you didn’t bother looking at the other slot and when I asked those slot, it’s clear you haven’t really read those slot.
This raises the question why they didn’t attack N2~ I don’t believe they would leave Grey dead unless they feared another person would take over?