I think thereās a few other valid strategies, but it means more than anything that the Cult Leader isnāt concerned about dying at night, probably.
Whichā¦ eh. Thereās not much BD killpower.
I just thought of one other thing that strongly implicates Yellow as BD King, but I kind of want to save it for nowā¦ if Iām wrong, I donāt want to give them an out.
If you really want me to say it now, I will, but I do think Iām in the right to withhold this for now.
Probably correct, although a Marluxion <-> GreyDragon debauchery isnātā¦ that unreasonable to do, imo. One Iād probably do.
Mostly because the fact that Napoleon could be converted without any protection was public information. It couldnāt be stopped, so itās both the most free but most obvious target.
Hindsight is 20/20 obv but their claim was like, absolutely ridiculous to do as anything that wasnāt merc
wtf past katze why did u do this
Rereading these posts kiiiinda felt like Marshal holding punches back on min? Like, at the surface, itās not completely clear. If you read the words without reading the intent, you might call that a crazy claim.
My concern lies in the fact that Marshal is very quickly trying to move on from min, to bury a Neutral claim over someone she allegedly scumreads.
The words in green are the ones that feel like Marshal is trying to retreat out of this, while the ones in red feel like theyāre there to give off the impression that she has actual intent in getting min killed. The one line is yellow is the one thatās giving me more pause, cause I kind of believe that regardless of mins alignment that she might be holding back due to the game.
(For the record, part of my read on min here was that I thought they were Prince)
I feel like Marshal kind of takes the out I give her here in a way that would reinforce my last thoughts, butā¦ her first reply to me has this sort of genuine annoyance that makes me think that Iām wrong and that Marshal was just trying to shade V!min.
So uh. Pretty sure Marshal was never a Squire. Just an honest to god scumslip right there.
moment.
Would be hilarious if PKR was a wolf as well, and both wolves misunderstood Squire.
Going back to āMarshal and min are unaligned.ā from this.
My initial reaction was āOh, and Marshal is probably not wolves with Napoleon, either.ā butā¦ maybe theyāre confused because they should have appeared as the same alignment?
Hmm.
Nah. I donāt think theyāre both starting, and I think if Nap was the N1 convert that Marshal prooobably doesnāt die to the bear?
ā¦probably.
Why am I in the Marl/Nappy zone Iām not Nappy or Marl!!!
With Marshal flipping wolf, and very likely being the starting Ritualist ā Iām currently very unsure how I feel about Napoleon and Marshal keeping up the argument under the assumption Marl was a Princess. Despite it being very obvious he was not one.
Kind of think itās another point for them not being W/W, which wasnāt my first impression, but I think Marshal would try to drop it entirely if they were both wolves, or go for a hellbus on Nappy. They seemed a bit stuck in the headlights, instead.
Shrugze. Iām going with my brain and saying Nappy isnāt a wolf as of Day 3. Canāt speak for N3 convert.
Okay guys I townread Yellow and I was going to justify it.
And I realized that I was probably giving Yellow a bit too much credit for some of the reads I was explaining. Basically I remember liking their Day 1 and early Day 2 but I completely forgot what I liked exactly and tried to find posts to remind myself why I liked them and it didnāt connect for me.
But I still think they are Town because:
They donāt feel like they are coordinated with Marshal. This is kind of a bit hard to explain as most of what I remember comes from Allies chat.
More importantly, I think Marshal clearly intended to pocket Yellow and I feel strongly about this one. Working through a thought process of both a V/W and W/W I think the former is more likely and I think a lot of Marshalās posts showcase this
Iām gonna try and keep this description as much as possible whilst not putting any conclusions here.
The first half of allies was just me and Marshal, Yellow wasnāt there.
I suggest Appelsiini as an OE target, quite firmly, in fact and Marshal agrees completely.
Then we just talked about a bunch of other players. Ask if you have any questions about any specific one.
Then Marshal leaves thread.
A while later itās me and Yellow in the thread.
We talked about Appelsiini being the OE target.
Then I talk with Marshal again while Yellow is outside thread but for EoN we are all there. I donāt actually think there is anything meaningful in this conversation so Iām excluding the details, but if youāre interested you can ask.
I think one thing to mention though is that it never seemed like that Yellow entirely understood the reasons why I and Marshal āsuspectedā her. It seemed more of a sheep than actual belief in the execution. Yellow seemed to suspect players like GreyDragon and ATN more.
I also want to address the fact that her argument that she wouldnāt claim Ritualist block as it was risky.
But thatās fallacious in the sense that Marshalās argument boiled down to āWell this action is dumb so I wouldnāt do itā, implying that because she said she wouldnāt do it, she wasnāt scumā¦
But if it was so dumbā¦ then why would I do it? Because I did the same thing and claimed Rit blocked The fact remains that it was done by one of us and we cannot take anyoneās word for why it wasnāt done.
Sorry katze Iāll get to your points
Anyways not an important thing to say but this is a matter of pride so i had to say it lol
^^ Key terms āThis post is good. Itās just goodā
^^ Putting down Marluxion so Yellow can be King. I think Marshal truly believed that she wouldnāt be able to properly influence Marluxionās OE if he were crowned. This post though could be for Yellow being either alignment though but I do think itās indicative of why Marshal might not want Marl to be king, from a wolf perspective. I say this because I think Marshal very well wanted to be able to influence the OE.