Nier+Drakengard Forum Mafia (Town Victory - This Silence is Mine: 7/29)

[Margaret]

Im sorry

Im watching the Smash 3.0 release

[Geyde]

@Maxwell

@Solic

Are you scum Hja?

@Solic

You’re missing your day 0 peek. I wonder why that is…

@Solic

Scum spotted!

These first three posts reek to me in terms of syntax. I dislike use of the eye emoji and these attacks are really made without justification.

@Solic

oh my god this is the Dutch way of saying hi. I don’t know why seeing that excites me. Is it the same in Japan?

There is a huge difference between off topic but still meaningful fluff and just wasteful, fluff for fluff’s sake fluff. This is definitely the latter.

@Solic

Why does this post come from Geyde…

Geyde is always aggressive and it seems odd that Solic would emphasize this.

@Solic

Okay Maxwell has won me over again.

I don’t believe the post I made that led to this was that powerful. Recently, I’ve always been fiery when I’ve felt it was just to be so. It is odd to me that town would reverse their read on me so fast.

@Solic

First you want me to relive Eevee’s game and then you ask this. What’s next.

Why post this? Again, this is not only fluff but meaningless and wasteful.

Maybe I’m over-analyzing this, but to me there is a lot of stuff here, and I heavily distrust repeated use of the eyes emoji, as well.

You are over analyzing for sure.
Emojis are NAI for Solic.

Nothing you mentioned really sells a scum case

[Maxwell]

I guess not. I’m just uneasy. I also agree that Math is trying desperately to capitalize on a mistake by Met that with further analysis doesn’t really resonate as a mistake.

[Geyde]

@Mercenary

@Mercenary

I don’t get why so many people seem to think that wolves are only allowed to indirectly defend other wolves, consdering that Whiteknighting is very much a thing.

This is mild shadethrowing and would be harmless if he wasn’t on scum lenses for the next comment Geyde quoted.

Because it’d be so much easier to jump on and pressure Geyde, rather than defend them like that. Like, why go to the effort to allow someone you could potentially mislynch to compose themselves and defend themselves?

@Mercenary

As for your point, while I agree that Geyde would somewhat be tempting there are a few things to remember;

1. Wolves are far more acutely aware of villager’s villagetells than villagers are, and thus are far more paranoid when it comes to jumping onto wagons.
2. Wolves don’t make perfect plays, and sometimes don’t make them on purpose for WIFOM reasons.

Icibalus is overextending way too much to attempt to get Boss to look suspicious, saying in 1 that he is defending Geyde because he would be afraid when Geyde was “cleared” (and it also implies that Ici either has a very strong townread on Geyde or he knows Geyde is town) due to their villagetells, and in 2 Ici proposes that Boss would have a line of thought of “I will prevent people from pushing further this villager to defend them, even if suddenly defending them will make me suspicious and risk myself for no good reason, in the vain hope that people will actually think I’m town for that.”

I don’t think it’s enough to damn Ici. It’s scummy for sure but I’d wait to follow through

[Geyde]

Math isn’t scum

[Geyde]

He’s alone af in thread

[Maxwell]

You know it’s possible scum are intentionally abandoning him to make it seem this way.

[Mercenary]

I still see it better than a Math or Solic wagon, so why no

[Geyde]

No way.
Scum working with Math is far more common if he is actually scum. That’s just a horrible idea to leave your best player to dry

[Maxwell]

if not ici, you think math is town, and aren’t sold on a solic scum case, who?

[Geyde]

Look at the context of those posts.
They are responding

[fireslol]

This is like watching a movie.

[Geyde]

Met

[Maxwell]

Are you serious?

[Margaret]

My emotions went through too many stages for the Smash 3.0 update log

[Mercenary]

needlessly to say, I personally also find an ici wagon better than a merc one

@Geyde

Look at the context of those posts.
They are responding

Yes, but they still seem to be exaggeratedly pushing an agenda towards incriminating Boss.

[Geyde]

Pretty much.
I can see flawed logic with the other ones

/vote Meteoro

[Maxwell]

I’ll review his ISO and re-analyze over the next few hours.

[Geyde]

@Mercenary

needlessly to say, I personally also find an ici wagon better than a merc one

@Geyde

Look at the context of those posts.
They are responding

Yes, but they still seem to be exaggeratedly pushing an agenda towards incriminating Boss.

Could they just be discussing their scum read and defending their position on it

[Geyde]

I agree that them pushing boss how they did is shitty and that they are possible - likely scum, but Ici really hasn’t done enough terrible shit.