One Night Ultimate Werewolf - Village Wins

if you were to print it out, you would

Which is why no one is rushing to print it out

yeah because ONUW is just better

How does that make it better just because it’s designing within the constraints of physical reality?

Also if you want to get technical you could get all of those roles to work IRL if you are willing to put some work in

if your game is ONUW then it should play like ONUW

Well my game is A Heist Gone Wrong

It is comparable to ONUW but they are separate games

also

these are impossible and others are highly impractical and less fun

some of them are just bad without the physicality element anyway

For Tracker you can have everyone give themselves (and bottom cards) a blank token. Then have the Tracker swap his token out for a special tracker token. Then swap tokens with the cards. Tracker then gets to see every token at the end of the night

again, highly impractical

also why would you wanna be a tracker when insomniac is better

Why would you want to be an apprentice seer when seer is better?

exactly

by which i mean it’s less fun for the player

obviously i appreciate the fact that you should try and make rolelists balanced

Oh and for the record the answer is that Tracker can sometimes be better when multiple swaps are involved

ehhh

I don’t see it

Robber steals your card and is then swapped by a troublemaker. Tracker can confirm both swaps while the insomniac can only confirm the SL

SL = Shoplifter = Robber btw