This post kind of implies that Officer isn’t suspicious but Facilitator had not stated a read on them beforehand. Not sure what to make of this though, since Officer was being v read by most of the thread at this point so they could just be sheeping consensus here?
Every single one of their reads I find to be super genuine. The way they handled security feels very unlike how a wolf would ever approach it. Like I just really really think their reads are borderline unfakeable.
Stuff like this I really just truly do not think a wolf ever is able to think of
1 Like
I still pretty strongly prefer a facilitator kill but scientist is among the weakest of my clears
I’ll take a look at that when I have access to a computer; thanks Trap.
Trap when you get a chance can you backread Scientist? I personally don’t see how that long chain of posts you quoted is villagery. It seems more playstyle indicative to me.
Trapsetter
Student
Cryogenics
Security
Teleporter
^ Struggle seeing a wolf in the above ~ever. Maybe security if scientist is a wolf but thats a super out there pairing.
Officer
Scientist
^ Think these 2 are town but have the least on them tbh
Facilitator
^ I’d like to kill this.
I completely forgot I even had this thought… I remember thinking Coroner/Facilitator was not a likely team, I guess this was why. So I wouldn’t be surprised if the game doesn’t end by killing Facilitator, actually.
However, I’m reaching the point where I’m staking the game on Officer/Scientist/Facilitator ending it.
I completely agree with this, although I’m less sure on Security. If we lose to someone in here, it’s probably Security.
Even though Security hasn’t been explicitly villagery, the way they’re posting kind of feels like it’s coming from a confident albeit uninformed perspective. It’s fakeable, but not really something I can just disregard.
I have a theory about Security that I am not sure if I am supposed to share.
Will out if people want but idk if it’s optimal for me to do so.
Trap’s PoE is really clean and makes a lot of sense.
Think we should concentrate our efforts on not losing to anyone in here because if we clear all of these people as villager then we win.
Trapsetter
Student
Cryogenics
Security
Teleporter
I include myself for posterity, but I’m not a wolf.
Can we talk about this guy?
I think that’s the only one in the group who has a realistic chance of flipping wolf.
hello
cryo and him are same checked by me
Security is only wolf in the world where Scientist/Security are the wolf team.
Well, this isn’t actually unthinkable. By the time we flip Scientist (if the game hasn’t already ended or there’s no glaringly obvious reason to put them above anyone else) I could still be alive? …Although once again, if they’re Sympathizer that actually kind of screws us.
I was thinking Scientist’s flip could prove Security and Cryo, but then again Sympathizer exists.
You know, the sheer existence of Sympathizer affects the game a whole lot, moreso than any actual active influence almost any player would have as the role.
Then again, if Scientist is Sympathizer deliberately misclearing one of Cryogenics/Security, one of them would have had a pretty weird response to this, right? I don’t recall this happening off the top of my head.
The role is similar to Jester and Scorned where they are roles which can affect the game just by the power of their name alone.
I swear I remember writing a contract using your own blood that stated if you didn’t solve the game by D3 you were lock scum, are you busy right now still?
I have some paranoia but like…I’m pretty sure the list is clear (besides obviously security + scientist). I also don’t think I will ever be able to catch them solely based off today alone if one of those is a wolf, I’ll have to see how they react later in the game because that’s where wolves sometimes slip up with their agenda