variations dont always cancel each other
How does scum!Whysper know where Marshal would have visited? How would they have a PGO ready for her to die on?
Pigeon said it himself: Everyone knows Marshal is Texan, so it directly correlates with her.
Ergo, it is very likely that Pigeon’s action has something to do with Marshal.
Variations don’t… sorta I think.
I asked hosts if a doc + giving someone BP were considered the same thing and hosts said no
Also I like how everyone paints these obsecure mafia universe roles and expects Merc and Sulit to instantly know what roles they are referring to
1 Like
my theory, as i said before is that pigeon’s action was not interpreted as a vig nor even targeting marshal
whysper is a wolf and her actual action was vigging or in some other way killing marshal, claiming that she visited a random person as a cover up action that’s reasonable for someone to have, but just before claiming it marshal’s logs were posted and she changed the random person to pigeon so everything matches up
aelin really did roleblock marshal which would mean whysper’s visit was fake, and is also at least one of the wolves in whysper/zone/wind
the only problem this has is that if visits were canceled to marshal, then she wouldn’t have been able to be targeted by a vig, which suggests she really did just die to pigeon
why did aelin have to make her action so ambiguous
That piece of line could have been interpreted as a gun. That’s my first thought anyway.
Oh. Well, then who shot Marshal?
Arc what makes you think Mafia didn’t try to roleblock cancelling out Aelin’s actions?
i don’t think mafia would roleblock anyway, but if they did they definitely wouldn’t roleblock aelin who was probably targeting marshal with a negative ability… which she did
Cool, so please tell me which variation of a Vig killed Marshal?
Okay, but this theory relies on Whysper somehow finding a way to kill Marshal without getting cancelled from duplicate drawings.
Given that we are talking about a Vig here, I find that very unlikely.