PJO FM - 3/13 - Demigods (Town) Wins!

[Alice]

I think pigeon’s vote was wolfy since he just voted and then tried justifying it, but progression cases in general don’t usually work.

[Luxy]

What is town play

[thepigeonnyc]

Me sheeping Cloned is my progression

[Luxy]

Why did you sheep cloned

[thepigeonnyc]

I just found him to be very convincing

[Luxy]

What was his argument?

[Alice]

You just ninja’d me lmao.

[Marluxion]

Go on

[thepigeonnyc]

@clonedcheese

you just seem to know that I am V

This

[Luxy]

Why did you have to go look to find the reasoning?

If it was so convincing wouldn’t you just remember it?

[thepigeonnyc]

Admittedly I disagree with past me, idk what I was thinking

[Alice]

@thepigeonnyc

It started as a sheep of a TMI accusation and then I wanted to make my own takes. Claiming that you can somehow auto-win the game for Town when the example Town role is:

@Aelin

Night: Up To No Good - Pick a player and… watch over them for the night. See who visits them and who they visit. (2 Uses)

causes me to highly doubt your claim is true

@Luxy

Actually he kind of has a point.

[thepigeonnyc]

I agree with my personal reads, not the sheeping.
/vote Marluxion @Aelin @Mistyx. Much stronger argument for voting him

[Luxy]

I thought Alice claimed self-resolving not ‘win us the game’

[Alice]

What about the TMI accusation?

[Luxy]

Although that thought process is definitely townier from pigeon than what I’ve seen previously

[Luxy]

Pigeon flipflopping harder than a fish out of water

[thepigeonnyc]

I rescind it. Looking back there wasn’t really TMI there

[min]

@Nightingale

why am i having a panic attack ofer not being able to concretely find min villagery
this isnt fair
im supposed to be good at the game!

im town

Ez

@thepigeonnyc

Unless my memory is that bad, I remember telling Night that it was okay for her to take a break, nothing to do with Eli

???

@Nightingale

heres the problem.
nobody is villagery.
what is the solution?
everybody when you see this post is legally obligated to post 3 players who are town and 1 player who is a wolf, with reasoning. Going back to re-read the thread is fine. Even if you’re just making up hot garbage for your read, thats fine, as long as its something that you could concievably be convinced in this gamestate.

(I updated this while reading thread)

1. night villager cuz you’re actively spending effort making thread state better which is highly villagery imo
2. was gonna say honestly due to thread state honestly. saw his responses and threw that away quickly. Ive liked luxys posts because all of them genuinely just show thought processing and actual solving like…while reading it it doesnt look like shit posted just to exist as words it feels like all of what he’s said has purpose which is pretty villagery
3. I don’t know a lot about Alice but my mind is telling me to villa read her kinda for the amount she’s actually done analysis and other shit and I agree with a lot of what she says too so fuckit

@clonedcheese

I’ve practically said I’m the cop

we might as well have half the game claim at this point ever

@clonedcheese

@Alice

…please don’t claim like this.

even this

I’m surprised you take a cop claim with no info so easily

like there’s nothing to back it up, no additional thing I add by claiming, you just seem to know that I am V

what

this is not

like this is not an argument that you should be having because someone said not to openclaim ? ? regardless of alignment nobody needs to claim this early lol

cringe

@Alice

Not going to go deeper into it because anti-claim exists.

it does?

@thepigeonnyc

We can’t imagine that there’s a role that wins the game for town just by being kept alive. I have a feeling this is a Lying Darkness type role here

@Alice

How observant of you to deduce me as a 3p right when the setup literally says that the game is 10V/3W.

LOL

@Alice

This game’s just as easy as Emilia/Eli/Pidgeon, isn’t it?

idk

@thepigeonnyc

It started as a sheep of a TMI accusation and then I wanted to make my own takes. Claiming that you can somehow auto-win the game for Town when the example Town role is:

I dislike a lot of pigeons words

very much misconstruing Alices arguments.

w lean

@Luxy

This RT is >rand wolf

This seems like a copy of Alice’s but he rescinds it so quick its almost pointless?

I found it bad too

n0 redcheck at sod where gorta could clearly just scroll back lol

@Alice

You just ninja’d me lmao.

? wat does this mean im dumb

btw looking at what I was randed and the example it feels like Emilias role is stupidly broken unless thats like aelins thing

[min]

k brb