Purgatory 2 - Devils Definitely Did Cry - Lost Souls win!

[MathBlade]

You get nothing because A) it wont happen
And B) if it does as my case demonstrates scum would be suboptimal

[MathBlade]

There are no investigatives

I gave you your proof in my case interact with it

[MaximusPrime]

while you do make valid points, i am still more confident(possibly stupidly so) that icibalus is a demon

if the wagon does not shift to icibalus tomorrow(cause we still have around 40 hours i believe), then i will see if i need to vote someone else or not

best case scenario is that i convince you to vote ici imo

[MathBlade]

See here is the situation I am in.

You asked me to evaluate Ici

I did.

I came to the conclusion he is only scum with you.

So if you believe things to be different then you need to make a case for Ici scum and talk through some of my points and where I went wrong. You’re making the claim Ici is scum and you are town. The person making the claim needs to bring the evidence

[Icibalus]

/vote Solic

i really shouldn’tve joined this game, sorry for slanking s damned much.

[Marluxion]

Accused	Voters	Count
Solic	Ashe, MathBlade, Icibalus	3/4
MaximusPrime	NozBugz, MTheJoker	2/4
Icibalus	MaximusPrime	1/4
MTheJoker	Solic	1/4

Roughly 40 hours left until EOP.

[Solic]

The fuck. Don’t hammer me before I can make my case. I told you I was busy.

[Solic]

@MathBlade

Solic instead argues with OTB taking up precious time.

Yeah making sure that the person we vote up for heaven is actually town takes up a lot of precious time, because so much discussion was happening right. If you disagree with the arguments that I made, you should have addressed those.

[Solic]

@Ashe

hang on

NozBugz:

-If we go to judgement day, OTB votes Solic as demon

Did you just slip that we won’t go to judgement day if Solic was lynched? lol

I don’t see the slip here? He’s saying “if”?

@Ashe

Why I think Noz just slipped essentially is because if we lynch a demon here, we won’t go to judgement day. In their scenario, the only judgement day would be if Solic lived… so I’m thinking it’s a slip.

still don’t see it.

[Solic]

@Ami

@Marluxion can we do end game plans to speed this up?

This is a super susp post.

[Solic]

@Ashe

I’m confused on how I keep ending up on all your scum team guesses

Either way, I’m good to vote Max, Solic or Joker today, they all seem fairly scummy to me. (although I don’t have the words right now to explain why, more on that when I can formulate sentences a little better :p)

If you have your vote on me, that means you think I’m the scummiest, so please motivate it. Your last few posts have just been to sheep on whatever Math is saying.

[Solic]

@Icibalus

/vote Solic

i really shouldn’tve joined this game, sorry for slanking s damned much.

Also how opportunistic is this.

[Solic]

@MathBlade

If Max is town and there are two or more scum off the wagon, then quickhammering is necessarily advantageous for them because it turns into at best town’s shot is RNG.

If Max is town and there is only one scum off the wagon then they are playing a need to convince people to vote Max. Both Noz and Ici are relatively inactive though. This is possible only if Noz is indeed scum even though he is the more active of the two as he doesn’t want to be caught pushing town demise. Instead he attacks me and you chainsaw. This is the most likely world.

If Max is town and there is no scum on that wagon then scum are necessarily bussing a buddy here without reason. Why? Myself Noz Ici Max all town means 7-4 is three Solic Ashe and Joker would have to be scum and not doing anything here is dumb.

TLDR if Max is town Noz is scum

Converse assuming Max scum coming up.

@MathBlade

If Max is scum and there are no scum on the wagon then they are necessarily spread out looking for a counter wagon. Myself Noz Ici town necessarily means the other two scum in Solic Ashe Joker.

Solic is pushing Joker and Ashe and Joker aren’t really doing anything. This means that Max is scum and no scum on the wagon can be summarily discarded. In other words scum lack any concern of Max going to hell in that scenario.

If Max is scum then one or more scum would be attempting to get towncred off of the wagon. Except no one is really pushing Max the votes are old and crusty. Noz’s latest interaction is to poke me and the ONLY person who could get any towncred is Ici but his play is so unremarkable as to not merit it.

This necessarily makes Max town.

Based on prior arguments Max town with one scum on the wagon makes the most sense.

Combined with Noz’s slip at the start of the day Solic Noz looks hella likely.

I just want to say to everyone that this hinges on the fact that Math is town as well. Note that all his theories rely on people that have not flipped yet too. If you would be attacking my vote on Parfait or my attack on OTB. Fair enough, but this is just a convoluted post to set yourself up is what it feels like.

/unvote I’ll need some time to figure this out.

[Solic]

/vote Ici I want more from you. Most interactions you have are with Max and now you suddenly sheep me out of nowhere.

@Icibalus

Please address your vote.

[Icibalus]

there’s nothing I can say but “I’ve been unable to fully participate due to other games and comittments, and quite frankly sheeping Math isd the best chance I have of voting a wolf today”

yes i know i’ve become everything I despise but you’re expecting me to get real analysis from a half-dead game.

i will note it’s very interesting that this is the THIRD interaction where you read a villager as wolf you’ve had this game; very interesting, isn’t it?

[Solic]

@Icibalus

i will note it’s very interesting that this is the THIRD interaction where you read a villager as wolf you’ve had this game; very interesting, isn’t it?

Allegedly, also I wasn’t reading OTB as full on wolf, but not the towniest person at that moment. Do none of you understand the announced pressure is no pressure adage… (or do you pretend to )

[Ami]

[MathBlade]

I did address them when I could. It happened to be after the flip but it was immediately so

[MathBlade]

@Ami

We lynch Maxi/Solic
-If we go to judgement day, OTB votes Solic as demon
-Next phase we send Math to heaven
-hell phase we send joker to hell

The slip is as follows:

Assume in the plan above lynch Solic in step one which Noz suggested. There is no mention of what to do on judgment day.

Assume we lynch Max, Noz says if there is a judgment day Noz says to vote Solic. Noz says the game wouldn’t end.

[MathBlade]

Ergo Max should be 100% voting Solic here but he isn’t.