hot take
katze and chloe are backing eachother up and they know eachother or at least think they know
so v/v or w/w
i don’t know if this take is actually hot
Eli not forcing a v/w dichotomy there makes me happy
and i wanna say its villagery tbh lmfao
1 Like
the above posts are self explanatory i think
the tmi part was a joke
still v reading you
me putting you in my towncore
explained here, i thought the vote was ~about how W!Arete votes a villager when their teammate is under pressure (and still do)
okay so this wasn’t actually about you i was just trying to be subtle in front of gorta but i thought marshal would have a similar reaction to me upon gorta posting the “i know how to read derps” posts
in fact
the only reason i pinged gorta for this was for his read on derps because i know how gorta treats his read on derps and if he didn’t reply in ~about the way he did i’d call it wolfy (most likely)
this is why i emphasized that ybw had replaced in because i didn’t want to have him derpclear or something
i read this and agreed with it
fuck it
lets go
vote arete because i think marshals post actually held validity, you aren’t as obv V as you were there
your posts are villagery but your pushes arent
i think i said this in another post already
do you have any more question Arete “Nerd” Lastname or am i free to go back to my dilemma of “which game do i play”
I disagree, I currently read katze as a wolf and Chloe as a villager and I don’t think this is Inherently Flawed, although they know each other well they aren’t perfect the-other-one readers (e.g. katze misread Chloe in WoW specchat albeit for bad reasons, and he spent ?most? of Morphogenetic Mafia thinking she was clear, I’m not actually sure if Chloe has villaged against scum!katze but I don’t think it’s out of the question that katze could fool village!her)
like obviously if I’m right about katze I’ll try and give some reconsideration of my Chloe read but I don’t think being wrong is inherently always wolfy
1 Like
I cannot get engaged with the gamestate as it is right now
I’m sorry
It’s basically just a friend group bantering around with each other in a way that’s annoyingly difficult to follow from the outside
And it’s really hard to get anything out of it for everyone else
1 Like
honest question arete
how much of your read on me is influenced by my role
because like
you’re currently looking at my progression but thats like the first thing i feel like you’ve actually brought up my posting and not mechanics
I feel like this doesn’t really make sense because even under the assumption that you’re a villager, my game in Zelda can basically be summarized by ‘your posts are villagery but your pushes arent’
like I don’t think I pushed a non-consensus wolf that game until EoD4, when Dobby started Isoing me to push me I was basically expecting to just die because I’d softdefended like half the wolves
My current read on you is TKTBABIGS but you ended up being [redacted] so who knows tbh
im pretty sure you had villagery pushes in that game but you were also just super fucking towny overall and you are less that
granted my read on you weakened because you did stupid FPSes (idk why people would FPS its just -EV) to push already outted wolves
i guess thats a bad push but its more like bad play :^)
I don’t know!!
I had to call this out but I don’t know if it’s like
anyone’s fault or anything that can be dealt with
im not going to say “chloe is literally ride or die on katze V so blame her if she’s wrong because that’s basically a cop check on me that isn’t foiled by my role” but like
…it kind of is, tbh
thatsthejoke.png
1 Like
some of it?
I would say it’s like
your roleclaim was like a big flashing neon sign that you were lying about something, and while ‘katze lying’ is not outside your townrange ‘lying about being a miller’ is super wolf-motivated
and I do think that’s leading to me giving you more scrutiny than other people – like, Chloe also put me in my towncore and then joined in on the Marshal CFD, and yet I find it to be wolfier from you than from her even though there’s not, like, a good reason for that
but your roleclaim isn’t the only reason I find you to be suspicious and when I’ve tried socially reading you I haven’t found reasons to townread you
Didnt we both lower arete quite a but bc if their EoD wrt nutella as well as their treatment of Thunal
I feel like
How i felt about arete’s EoD there is almost exactly on par with how i feel about arete’s EoD here
I also think it really depends on exactly what derps is
If hes a villager i’ll put arete under a microscope and check them out a LOT more, but if hes a wolf its… not as bad, unless hes like, a literal goon
okay
hm
are there people that you’re currently very unsure about who are not in the ‘mods plus Marshal and sulit for some reason’ group
ideally in a [metronome swinging back and forth] way more than a [shrug] way because that’s more interesting