WHY MARSHAL IS A WOOOOLF
Part I: Weird/Placating Reads
This is just ??? Marshal knows katzeâs wolfrange isnât this small right? It doesnât feel thought through.
yes this post was and still is ??? and ive never really been convinced it was real regardless of her alignment because W!Marshal can easily do better than this and V!Marshal⌠probably doesnât believe it? shrugze
Same as above. This feels like really flaky reasoning to put someone at 95% town, who has also shown to be a good wolf?
tbh i both think this is valid and invalid cause its like, a comment that, like marshal, i find significantly more likely to come from V!Chloe (or not at all) because sheâs VERY liable to feel guilty as shit saying this regardless, if it was a disingenuous comment i think sheâd probably crumble up and cry about it mentally
but chloe is capable of writing good posts as a woofer yes
Same as above!!
no comment (joycat color is a nice blue btw)
Same as above!!! Especially because min HAS gotten this angry before as wolf.
i think marshals confidence in this read has waned a bit, but i do think itâs a >rand to be correct read about most people
i donât know if min is one of those people tho
Reading katze off
of
bitchiness
yeah, no. this is a marshal thing. she fully believes in this tell. you can reread the autumn game, you can probably see her read on me change in real time during the zelda mash like i did once i progressively got less patient with people. this is a thing she believes. this is consistent. you might think itâs stupid, i think itâs kinda stupid, but she doesnât.
Like a lot of these reads just feel fuckin weird and not well thought out, and like sheâs just making them to placate people.
Part II: Weird Wind Interaction D1
Marshal never engages with Wind like, ever. She puts Wind at exactly null and never moves or comments on her, and during the wagon EOD on Wind she pushes Zone for no reason.
if marshal had more influence/impact on D1, iâd honestly consider this pretty villagery for her, but she kind of wasnât? like, okay, at a glance it doesnât look good. her vote ends up on Zone, a vanity wagon, at EoD. she wasnât trying to save Wind directly, despite having a strong enough claimed wolfread on Derps to very easily justify a vote on him over her.
that last part is, imo, important, because she WAS around for EoD. she was pushing zone over derps. what say you, @sulit?
Part III: Incessently Saying He Is Obvtown, Or Along Those Lines
I could have quoted more but I forgot to look as hard when I moved on with the iso. Marshal, probably every like 20 posts, says something along the lines of IM TOWN LOL. Its just overdone, performative, and wolfy. Please correct me if Iâm wrong but I donât think she does this as town, at least not this much. It feels like sheâs just trying to push it onto people in order to continue pushing agenda.
this is marshal. im not even reading this. its nai.
Part IV: Pushing Weird And Powerwolfy Angles
This reasoning is just? bad? I feel like itâs just throwing shade on Derps in a wolfy way, like even if Derps was a wolf I feel lilke heâd t ake advantage of the gorta read, and even them gorta wasnât that large of a topic.
wasnât this around the time in thread me/marshal were calling gorta obvtown? p sure derps claims to have a relatively confident gorta read as well
dont think this matters that much tbhtbh [color=orange]unless derps flips V[color]
This is just bad as well because Arete is literally in Marshals POE i canât tell if this is a joke post or not
ngl i feel like marshal had a bit of a âgotchaâ moment [PENDING REREAD OF THE âSUICIDE BOMBâ SITUATION] here, because⌠yes, marshal has been repping a wolfread on arete
arete knows this
you know this
i know this
sensei probably knows this with how much he sleeps on my fucking desk and how long ive threadcamped this game
but marshal is⌠not a bad FM player
i feel like theyâre relatively unlikely to actually do a hero suicide bomb like that and not just shoot someone whos more consensusy wolfread that they also believe (derps? hi)
and arete⌠probably knows that too?
so depending on their reaction i think this could easily be villgery for her lol
I probably could have found more of these as well i just forgot to look for them
Part V: Just Really Weird Interactions With My Slot???
This is a less strong point because only I know my alignment at the moment, but Marshalâs treatment of my slot from my standpoint is really wolfy. Marshal (from my pov at least) is one of the best at reading me, and he slaps a townread on me for ?anger? and then she just slowly drops me in her reads all d2 as I start to push her. She never engages with my read or talks to me or anything, and it feels wolfy, like sheâs trying to slip townies into his POE.
i donât think marshal is âone of the bestâ at reading you, for one, and you pushing that angle is 
in a game with chloe in it, arguably myself, arguably arete, idk.
id have to find what postnum your abhorrent readlist was on before i said for sure how terrible this is for marshal
but i will concede that her progression on you kinda is iffy, even if realistically i probably have given you too much creditze shrugze joyze
Part VII: App Progression
AT also slowly drops into POE for Marshal (and has flipped town) despite Marshal confidently saying the slot is town. She also rarely engages with the slot, and is now trying to claim towncred for defending it when she didnât really do so D2.
thereâs⌠plenty of posts where people are saying âYBW might be town? but they have to DO SOMETHINGâ, marshal also posted shit like this! 99% sure of that! why are you exlcuding that, when itâs obviously relevant to her read on that slot??? you arguably have one post mentioning it but like, there was DEFINITELY more
actually fuck it this iS VILLAGERY FOR MARSHAL! IM SAYING IT! this is exactly what she did to read YBW in Morpho imo
YBW needed content for marshal to actually sieve through and she never got that content
this is reasonable progression!!!
Part VIII: Wolfy Zone Push
The EOD1 Zone push is just so fucking wolfy. Why does she push Zone, instead of her already established and strong wolfread on Derps?? Additionally, she literally has NO REASON on why she is pushing Zone. It feels wolfy, and a possible way to get votes off Wind. Zone is consistently in Marshalâs POE and I havenât really seen why, or seen her do any actual analysis on Zone.
it was a unrealistic CFD to anyone with two eyes and marshal didnt vote derps to save wind at EoD in W!Marshal V!Derps worlds
wheres your god now, butter?
Part IX: Arete Push??
Marshal JUMPS on Arete for katâs claim, which doesnât even confirm a LW exists. More scummy if Arete flips town.
i thought arete was lost wolfy as fuck too so shrug im definitely biased
Part X: Other Things Iâm Too Lazy To Fit Into Their Own Category
Marshal like barely defends Eli before she leaves, then comes in today overexaggerating it and claiming towniness for it.
imo nai
shes either trying to milk towncred or is genuinely annoyed villager
Just donât like the Jane vote here
why
(this is like misc stuff that pinged me)
Part XI: Appealing To Townread Slots
Marshal ONLY appeals to Chloe at EOD, and she doesnât use any reasoning, itâs like sheâs just pleading that sheâs town and Chloe shouldnât kill her. She also does this to katze. It feels really wolfy because she is appealing to towncored slots instead of actually defending herself, and uses the âwe will lose the game if I die hereâ HEAVILY as a crutch. I just feel like town marshal wouldnât defend herself this way.
im not going to pretend she isnât hardcore pocketing me and chloe lol
Part XII: Mechshit
Marshalâs role, at least from my view, seems WAY overpowered compared to flip roles and my own, and I feel like the claim of protecting Chloe is just another way to pocket her.
mechanics are stupid and so am i
Thanks for coming to my tedtalk.
youâre not welcome
TLDR: Marshal relies heavily on saying sheâs obvious town or appealing to widely townread slots. I see very little in her iso thatâs actually towny, and sheâs going about making her POE in a way that feels powerwolfy.
text
