In my opinion
The people that are not derps that I want to kill are zone ā marl ā arete, roughly in that order.
Marl realistically has the least going for him
and tbh his pushes and play is incredibly erratic.
He randomly changed votes at multiple EoDs without warning
Heās thrown out very wild tinfoils on people I read strongly as villager
I still think heās town, which makes this toughTM, but I canāt do anything abt it. atm.
I can probably semi-confirm Gorta tonight
afaict he is claiming:
- not to have a night ability
- to be able to do exactly one of ākillā and āprotectā
and I think there are relatively few wolf roles that meet that criterion and are consistent with how the game has gone
maybe some sort of uberconditional dayvig
Arete has good posting and decent mechanics going for them.
But, like, if derps is wolf (which I think is very likely at the moment) their play is just incredibly wolfsided throughout the entire game, and they refused to listen to people they had as villagers when they challenged that worldview. I could see them as going full on powerwolf. They say āI donāt defend partners that arenāt tryingā but iirc derps was one of the highest d1 posters and argued hard to live, and at that point the min/centuries slot was not likely to endgame so it makes sense for w!arete to defend w!derps and keep him in the game. And after making a series of post calling derps obviously spewed villager, you canāt really just back down when derps stops trying.
Zone has gone above and beyond this game, but heās ābroken his metaā many times before. I cannot call him a villager off of meta, and his pushes and takes are just impossible to clear off of.
If derps is wolf, wind and derps (+1, most likely) were all in the thread and could kill zone and blame it entirely on me (arete and derps did vote zone so, like, I guess arete could be +1).
A lot of my takes are wildly preflipping derps but Iām gamer like that.
Deal with it
Itās very unlikely mafia have any roleblocking power so one of jane/night dies tonight realistically
Probably just jane.
can you walk me through your reasons for thinking litlit is V
if I can lock that slot in it would help a lot
Ok so like realistically
I donāt think she goes out of her way to fake the annoyance.
I know I said, like, exactly this about min, but sulit has throughout the game constantly gotten pissy at people wolfreading her or treater her (from her perspective) unfairly.
Like sheās been consistently very passive aggressive throughout the entire game, in a way that doesnāt feel like āIām a wolf frustrated at losing the game, let me channel that annoyance to look townieā, an more like a genuine "People are ignoring me and my top wolfread is consistently belittling my pushes and will probably try to CFD me
On top of this her posting has been, like, consistently pretty wimmy? Today was a drop (but tbf it was for the whole thread), and iād never clear her off of this alone, but I think sheās out of the āclassic sulit wolf metaā even if I donāt really believe in it.
Liked a few things in her wallpost.
Centuries consistently tried to shut down my v reads on that slot in a way that felt straight up opportunistic and sulitās handling of centuries himself was, like, fine? Hesitantly saying āI think heās wolf but heād get mad at me if I said itā isnāt really the way a wolf handles a partner in that situation? Itās noncommittal but openly so but I donāt think someone of her experience really handles it that way.
Her thunderdoming of PKR is realistically straight up not accidental. PKR was very blatantly trying to set himself and sulit up as w/w (although because I canāt see into his brain this has less stock than it seems).
Wolves putting a fakeclaim in thread would at least check if it didnāt mess with a partnerās claim. They COULD be w/w, going for a thunderdome instead of letting derps die, but it doesnāt make sense especially because I could have, like, not gone over.
Wind vote is also a good look if I didnāt say that already
Vote Count
| Accused | Voters | Number |
|---|---|---|
| SirDerpsAlot | Zone_Q11, Mistyx, Marshal, an_gorta_pratai | 4/6 |
| Arete | Jane, Marluxion, sulit | 3/6 |
| Zone_Q11 | Nightingale, Chloe, Arete | 3/6 |
| [Not voting] | SirDerpsAlot | 1 |
Iām marginally okay with arete dying.
However would prefer zone atm even if Iām having my own doubts?
@Chloe last time I was an IC i cfdād off of tied w/w wagons onto a village appelsiini with 2 minutes left in the ay
i feel like arete/derps is probably the best move here because i think like
fairly high odds of 1 wolf between them, just off of setup stuff?
but i dont think two
| Voted | Voters | Number of Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Derps | Zone, Mist, Marshal, Gorta | 4/6 |
| Arete | Jane, Marl, Sulit | 3/6 |
| Zone | Nightingale, Chloe, arete | 3/6 |
| Not Voting | Derps | 1 |