Actually, IDEK what others accuse her of.
I only want her defense in the form of a new readslist, because she has outright awful logic on me.
people need to stop saying that anything emotional or guilt-trippy is āAtEā
itās only AtE if itās intentionally used as a tactic
calling someone who is genuinely upset using āAtEā is hurtful as either alignment
itās not like, toxic or anything, because AtE is a legitimate part of the game!
but it still heavily toes the line about invalidating peoples emotions which is why i try not to do it!
2 Likes
Actually, I take the last part back.
@Jane, why do you bother defending Marshal?
Letās assume that you are right about how suspicious it is that nobody bothered to defend Marshal.
If Marshal is town, is it really worth it to let her live when her reads are outright bad?
Why do you keep her alive, when she scumreads you? Did you read her argument on her scumread on you, and agree to it? Did you do nothing to improve your own image on her reads?
unrelated and chloe mentioned this earlier i think
but the entire threadstate is unnecessarily fixated on marshal!
Marshal might be a wolf, but even if so, itās unproductive to spend 60 hours of discussion time soley to burying her!
3 Likes
night is goodposting rn
i dont think its really towny but its what needs to be said and i already have her as hard town anyway
1 Like
Because Iām pretty sure theyāre a Villager!
As far as I know their only argument is that I shouldnāt get credit for voting Wind at EoD and generally not being impressive. This makes perfect sense since they thought the wagons were W/W.
Iām currently destroying my own credit from Wind because I think they were right about Derps being a wolf.
Thatās cool and all, but AtE is what I see Marshal do to keep herself alive.
I even rescinded my argument of her using AtE at one point because I think that she was unintentionally emotional, but when I saw that she just gave up after I gave her a chance and waited hours for her revised readsā¦ Nothing can really save her from getting a bad image.
i dont feel like theres anything inherently bad about zone taking this line of argument, i just feel like
its a think that can only be understood by experiencing the other end of it
I do agree on your opinion, and Chloe already tried to start a new topic with Areteā¦
But I am afraid that their plan never came to fruition.
To put it simply:
- āWe donāt know who else is a better candidate to execute, other than Marshal.ā
- āEveryone else are either towny or null.ā
Give me about 5 quotes of her which made you think that she is town.
*breathes for 30 seconds*
Jane. If we are to execute Derps Todayā¦ would you promise me to unconditionally vote Marshal no matter what on D3?
IDK how to read Derps/Marshal.
It could be that she tried to CFD unto me as to protect her scumbuddy Derps.
It could be that she was opportunistically trying to CFD the guy who made everyone uncomfortable.
Either way, regardless of the truth, I have her deadset as scum.
If I were to give her another chance, then I want it to be her last.
I feel like marshal/derps need to be resolved somehow
and this seems like good use of thread discussion?
i donāt get why itās a problem if weāre not driving another discussion out and weāre likely lynching one of them
if anyone wants to talk about someone else go ahead idk whats stopping you wowee
Basically, there is a faction of people that thinks Derps is spewed town by Wind,
and there is a faction of people that disagree with that spew, and think that EOD1 was W/W.
Marshal/Derps indeed needs to be resolved, except we have no other way to resolve it other than by having one of them be executed, whichā¦ wonāt happen for at least 24 hours.
There is no problem in making a new discussion/topic, except that ājust about everyoneā doesnāt have a better discussion/topic to talk about.
My main reason for thinking they are Town is the threadstate and them giving up.
Iāll probably towncase them tomorrow but I currently have the energy of a deflated balloon.
It is currently D3, and no, Iām not voting Marshal tomorrow.
Summary
wolf marshal lives to lylo because everyone has cold feet about lynching her
we lose
1 Like
also if ppl are gonna find marshal as a villager thats cool i can be lazy
i just looked at the playerlist
i dont even explicitly scumread derps but like
wow i can list liek 3 reasons every player is a villager and then derps exists