im probably going to vote sulit
they look to me like theyre grasping for reasons not to thunderdome PKR
which is a wolfy mindset
1 Like
pkrs later posts completely invalidate my above read
hhhhhhhhhhh
i still think sulit is wolfy for it but requires more evaluation
2 Likes
But like, I donāt think this should be in essence a thunderdome.
I want others to flip before Sulit does because I believe her. I just do.
If we ever flip something which messes with dark votes, dark voters, investigativesā¦ or is a rolecop/investigative for mafia then Iām going to basically have her in my lock-clears
I cannot think of a single role that anyone but you could have to mess with that result
Then someone is lying about their claim then.
Or someone has more to it than theyāve admitted.
There is a difference check between you and sulit
By refusing to acknowledge this, you are actively damaging townās win chance in any world where you are a villager and sulit is a wolf, which is incredibly likely at this point
And you have no reason to believe this other than your own personal read
Quite frankly, if you are a villager here, you are holding the game hostage because you are so confident youāre right
This is legitimately worse than any hero vig shot
If you are a villager, this is borderline gamethrowing
2 Likes
Yes, but others are saying the liar has to be me or sulit.
And Iāve presented ways where it doesnāt has to be either of us.
If sulit is genuinely what she claims to be, which I believe she is, Iām saving an āI told you soā for post game
Well what do I do then?
Just accept itās a thunderdome despite believing itās not?
To vote someone Iām townreading?
At least try to find and push wolves outside of the thunderdome
Instead of voting yourself and hard shielding a player who you functionally have a red check on
okay so heres my refined read
PKRs mindset makes sense coming from a villager and from a wolf
As a wolf, they donāt want to be thunderdomed. Easy.
As a villager, it makes total sense to reject thunderdoming one of their townreads when theyāve been burned by mechanics many times over in many previous games. PKR states this is the case, and works off of this. It doesnāt look panicked or desperate, but it could be construed as agenda.
Yes itās very unlikely someone would mess with the result, but itās not unreasonable for V!PKR to think this after a situation like Spak/Light in Umineko 2 sucked up thread air for 2 full in-game days.
Sulit was struggling out of the thunderdome with their first posts, trying to say that āwhat if PKR isnāt a darkvoterā and āwhy would w!PKR block gorta.ā
Iā¦ canāt see a way to justify this mindset as a villager. It just looks like a perspective slip.
3 Likes
Technically it is possible that you two are V/V if there is a redirector who redirected you for some reasons beyond me. But Occamās Razor tells me: āNah. Itās either PKR or sulit. End of discussion.ā
Whatās the worth of your townread when their claim contradicts yours?
Surely you arenāt going to tell me that you would townread someone who you have redchecked?
Iām fucking losing my mind rn.
/Unvote
We need to look for wolves outside of me/sulit because I guess this is my next best thing which Mist pointed out.
Iām trying to make sure Iām not making mistake
Mistake or misinterpretation here could possibly mean 2 villagers dying and i dont really want that to be my fault because i fucked up or something
so im trying to think of other possibilities besides pkr is lock scum
i understand contradiction but im looking at other things too
