Insert titans of WW copypasta
okay but I was responding to your argument which was that, if youāre wolf, you defending Eli makes him also a wolf
āit makes more sense for me to defend w!Eli rather than v!Eli because it tightens the PoE and makes the game harder for me to winā
idk how to explain this point but like
Eliās alignment is fixed
you defending him (regardless of your alignment) doesnāt change it, if youāre a wolf then your choices are ādefend Eli,ā āpush Eli,ā or ādonāt do either, maybe defend/push someone elseā not ādefend wolf Eliā ādefend village Eliā
I think I explained that really badly
Thereās no way you read the last ~100 posts and your reaction is to vote Marshal harder.
wow itās almost like I specifically explained why aspects of his progression didnāt make sense as W/W rather than being like āVul is TMIing Eli V which makes Vul a wolf and Eli a villagerā
fwiw I vaguely remember her doing that in a previous game
admittedly I donāt remember which game so I could be misremembering details
I feel like this comparison fails to account for key features of their Isos, like, say, the fact that Bluelanceās Iso has 13 posts before he replaced out where Atlasās Iso has 372
like if you read Atlasās first 13 posts theyāre not super amazing either, >rand V but I wouldnāt go beyond that just from those posts
and I think Vul is smart enough to think of things like āmaybe directly comparing two people with an order of magnitude difference in post count and saying the one who contributed more is therefore villagerier is flawed logicā as town
okay but like
even the day before MyLo, no one as scum is like āmy townreads are my Mafia partners and my scumreads are the villagersā
and yeah, theyāre more likely to be townreading consensus villagers than PoE villagers but they arenāt incapable of doing the latter? like if you give me an arbitrarily chosen game that went to LyLo/MyLo I could probably find examples of wolves townreading PoE villagers close to MyLo, like any game, it doesnāt have to be specially chosen
(also by this same argument if youāre convinced Iām a wolf my partners would be exactly Eli/Blizer since both are potentially elimable and Iām defending them. I note that you are currently voting Derps, so either Iām a villager, or your current push makes no sense, or your logic is wrong)
as wolf he doesnāt have to care about his logic being right he just has to care about (pushing agenda/looking solvy) depending on which heās trying to do
I do think he would normally try to avoid having logical gaps like that but he might have missed it since having good logic wasnāt what he was focusing on, or he might have figured no one would notice
did you go into this Iso with the goal of determining Blizerās alignment or of proving Blizerās alignment
for Godās sake Arctic how hard is it to set aside your ego and your āthese people are Mafia because if they arenāt Iād have to admit to being wrongā attitude for one fucking day