[SFM] Candlelight [The Beasts Achieve Victory]

[Arete]

Plane time nowish

See you all in a couple hours

[Kyle20]

Can’t you just trust I have a good reason for now

[Kyle20]

And believe me when I say it’s actually a good reason

[PoisonedSquid]

Alright, I’m back. Technically, the “thunderdome” is for me and Uni, but I think Arete’s more likely to be scum which makes Eevee think that they’re town for some reason even though I’m neutral on them.

Arete’s been feeling unnatural to me with the way they kept changing their opinions on things and pocketing some people

[Arete]

Not on a plane any longer

[Arete]

@Kyle20

Can’t you just trust I have a good reason for now

We’re in MyLo

I don’t think there’s a reason more important than not immediately losing the game

[Arete]

@PoisonedSquid

Technically, the “thunderdome” is for me and Uni, but I think Arete’s more likely to be scum which makes Eevee think that they’re town for some reason even though I’m neutral on them.

I have no idea what this sentence is saying

[Arete]

@PoisonedSquid

pocketing some people

can you actually give examples or are you just baselessly shading?

[PoisonedSquid]

Actually, I can give examples. I’d just need to search hard for them because someone didn’t list SoDs and EoDs cough

[Arete]

You can Iso Kai if you’re looking for SoD/EoD

[PoisonedSquid]

@Arete

So I’m assuming this is a reactiontest because … it’s Marshal … but if not I don’t really see the harm in keeping him around?

@Arete

Not going to lie my first thought was that Marshal was scum and had tried to pull a JoJo 2.0

Flip flop potato

@Arete

Tinfoil: PKR and Possessed are partners, and PKR is trying to fakeslip them as not W/W

@Arete

Make the clock tick down

If you don’t want the clock to tick down then why are you trying to kill the person who probably makes it tick down by 25 hours

thinking face

S h a d i n g

@Arete

Arete, tell me… how are you confident this is true?

I think the vastly most likely options are (a) lolreactiontesting Marshal or (b) he’s telling the truth – like I literally said two posts ago, I don’t see the motivation in scum!Marshal fakeclaiming neut here, especially since openneuting as actual neut nearly got him lynched in FoL25

(but your shade is noted)

More shading

Actually, you’ve been focusing on him a lot, Arete. It’s sounding like you think he’s most likely scum but now you’re trying to push the blame on you just because other people said the same thing

@Arete

Also if we lynch PKR today then depending on how Jake’s ability works he probably can check someone else (it’s optimal to lynch every day)

LAMIST
I’m sure Diggity has played an FM before, so there’s zero point in saying this

@Arete

“I have a role that’s bad for town, so I have to be town” - PKR, 2020

@Arete

See the funny thing is that I also reevaled and concluded that PKR is probably town, I think I was focusing too much on his obnoxious habit of declaring himself conftown off of claim but he does that as town too even when it makes zero sense (Looming Threat)

/vote Possessed

I think Possessed was trying to set us up as TvS to get both of us lynched off the other’s flip

More to come when off mobile

Here’s the unnatural pacing I was talking about. There’s no progression, there’s only “Hmmm, I’m shading hard on this person because I think they’re scum” to “Actually, that person’s town. The one that’s defending them is the scum here” in a few posts

@Arete

The roleclaim feels basically legit, I’m confident he’s telling the truth about his role because if he were lying he could get near-instantly outed

It’s not necessarily an inherently town-aligned role but I think the way that he outed it feels townie, as W Jake would basically be forced into semi-clearing a bunch of people and that would be minus EV for a wolf

so lolmechanics say he’s town

his pushes also feel different from the Cop13er but I don’t know if I could explain why particularly well

This aged well

There could be more posts I can find and quote here, but my stomach’s giving me trouble. I don’t know where this quote is, but the posts about saying that Vul’s secret reading method on me is saying I’m town sounds like you were trying to pocket me kind of like in Danganronpa

[Arete]

Arete: ‘Okay, if you actually think I’m pocketing people, then give examples’
Squid: ‘okay here are some quotes of Arete ever changing their mind/having a scumread/etc.’

[Arete]

@PoisonedSquid

S h a d i n g

this just in

ever having a scumread is shading

[Arete]

@Arete

Also if we lynch PKR today then depending on how Jake’s ability works he probably can check someone else (it’s optimal to lynch every day)

@PoisonedSquid

LAMIST
I’m sure Diggity has played an FM before, so there’s zero point in saying this

this … isn’t LAMIST

Like it’s so incredibly much not LAMIST that I think you’re probably just wrong about what LAMIST means, being this wrong doesn’t make sense as an intentional scum move (although obviously being wrong about definitions is NAI)

[Arete]

@PoisonedSquid

There’s no progression

It’s almost like we couldn’t post for two days

[PoisonedSquid]

Arete, I’m not just going to bend a knee to one simple thing. I need to sleep, so I can’t explain much, but I did mention about you townreading me just because of Vul’s guide instead of using your own judgement.

“It’s important to lynch every day” Everyone already knows that except for complete newbies which we both know Diggity wasn’t. What’s the point of saying something so obvious?

And I know you couldn’t post as much, but that’s mostly related to right now, not Day 1. You still have the most posts out of everyone else here and you didn’t make progression that seemed natural

[Arete]

@PoisonedSquid

but I did mention about you townreading me just because of Vul’s guide instead of using your own judgement.

I did literally the same thing in JoJo and I don’t remember you shading me for it there

@PoisonedSquid

“It’s important to lynch every day” Everyone already knows that except for complete newbies which we both know Diggity wasn’t.

Isn’t it like his second game? either way this was a fake thought when Luxy had it in FoL 24 and it seems like a pretty fake thought now, like I don’t actually believe you think that

@PoisonedSquid

And I know you couldn’t post as much, but that’s mostly related to right now, not Day 1. You still have the most posts out of everyone else here and you didn’t make progression that seemed natural

…I’m not saying “I had real life” I’m saying “we literally couldn’t post for two days because Kai locked down the thread”

shockingly one effect of this is that some people re-read the thread and come to new conclusions but can’t put down these conclusions because we can’t post in the thread whatsoever

[Arete]

@JakeTheWolfie

Can we not lynch PSquid.

@JakeTheWolfie

I don’t want to reveal why , but PSquid is important to my role.

@JakeTheWolfie

Is she important to your role in a way that points to her being town?

I would rather not.

@JakeTheWolfie

It does make me think PSquid is actually evil, but I would like to actually have a role to play instead of being stumped.

@JakeTheWolfie

Because if I can help it, I don’t want you lynched.

@JakeTheWolfie

Squid dying means that I become vanilla.

2024 is a particularly bad look for Squid

‘X is evil but I don’t want to lynch them’ is basically the most W/W interaction ever

[PoisonedSquid]

It wasn’t just around that period, Arete. There’s other instances where your progression was weird and I know someone quoted those posts, but I can’t search for them right now

[PoisonedSquid]

And please for the love of god don’t go “But Squid, you have to search for them right now! I need it right now!” even though it’s only a few minutes till midnight!